Epidemiology and Biostatistics Department, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), 550 16th St, 3rd Floor, San Francisco, CA, 94158, USA.
UCSF Institute for Global Health Sciences, San Francisco, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2021 Mar 6;21(1):453. doi: 10.1186/s12889-021-10453-0.
Stress and burnout among healthcare workers has been recognized as a global crisis needing urgent attention. Yet few studies have examined stress and burnout among healthcare providers in sub-Saharan Africa, and even fewer among maternity providers who work under very stressful conditions. To address these gaps, we examined self-reported stress and burnout levels as well as stress-related physiologic measures of these providers, along with their potential predictors.
Participants included 101 maternity providers (62 nurses/midwives, 16 clinical officers/doctors, and 23 support staff) in western Kenya. Respondents completed Cohen's Perceived Stress Scale, the Shirom-Melamed Burnout scale, and other sociodemographic, health, and work-related items. We also collected data on heart rate variability (HRV) and hair cortisol levels to assess stress-related physiologic responses to acute and chronic stress respectively. Multilevel linear regression models were computed to examine individual and work-related factors associated with stress, burnout, HRV, and cortisol level.
85% of providers reported moderate stress and 11.5% high stress. 65% experienced low burnout and 19.6% high burnout. Average HRV (measured as the root mean square of differences in intervals between successive heart beats: RMSSD) was 60.5 (SD = 33.0) and mean cortisol was mean cortisol was 44.2 pg/mg (SD = 60.88). Greater satisfaction with life accomplishments was associated with reduced stress (β = - 2.83; CI = -5.47; - 0.18), while motivation to work excessively (over commitment) was associated with both increased stress (β = 0.61 CI: 0.19, 1.03) and burnout (β = 2.05, CI = 0.91, 3.19). Female providers had higher burnout scores compared to male providers. Support staff had higher HRV than other providers and providers under 30 years of age had higher HRV than those 30 and above. Although no association between cortisol and any predictor was statistically significant, the direction of associations was consistent with those found for stress and burnout.
Most providers experienced moderate to high levels of stress and burnout. Individuals who were more driven to work excessively were particularly at risk for higher stress and burnout. Higher HRV of support staff and providers under age 30 suggest their more adaptive autonomic nervous system response to stress. Given its impact on provider wellbeing and quality of care, interventions to help providers manage stress are critical.
医护人员的压力和倦怠已被认为是全球危机,需要紧急关注。然而,很少有研究关注撒哈拉以南非洲的医疗保健提供者的压力和倦怠,更不用说在压力很大的情况下工作的产妇提供者了。为了解决这些差距,我们检查了这些提供者的自我报告的压力和倦怠水平以及与压力相关的生理测量结果,以及它们的潜在预测因素。
参与者包括肯尼亚西部的 101 名产妇提供者(62 名护士/助产士、16 名临床医生/医生和 23 名支持人员)。受访者完成了科恩的感知压力量表、希罗姆-梅拉米德倦怠量表以及其他社会人口统计学、健康和与工作相关的项目。我们还收集了心率变异性 (HRV) 和头发皮质醇水平的数据,以分别评估急性和慢性应激下与应激相关的生理反应。计算多水平线性回归模型,以检查与压力、倦怠、HRV 和皮质醇水平相关的个体和工作相关因素。
85%的提供者报告中度压力,11.5%报告高度压力。65%的人经历低倦怠,19.6%的人经历高倦怠。平均 HRV(以连续心跳之间差异的均方根表示:RMSSD)为 60.5(SD=33.0),平均皮质醇为 44.2pg/mg(SD=60.88)。生活成就满意度的提高与压力的降低有关(β=-2.83;CI=-5.47;-0.18),而过度工作的动机(过度投入)与压力的增加(β=0.61 CI:0.19,1.03)和倦怠(β=2.05,CI=0.91,3.19)有关。女性提供者的倦怠评分高于男性提供者。支持人员的 HRV 高于其他提供者,30 岁以下的提供者的 HRV 高于 30 岁以上的提供者。尽管皮质醇与任何预测因子之间没有统计学意义上的关联,但关联的方向与压力和倦怠的方向一致。
大多数提供者经历了中度到高度的压力和倦怠。那些更有动力过度工作的人特别容易面临更高的压力和倦怠风险。支持人员和 30 岁以下的提供者的 HRV 较高,表明他们对压力有更适应的自主神经系统反应。考虑到其对提供者幸福感和护理质量的影响,帮助提供者管理压力的干预措施至关重要。