Scanlon Donna M, Anderson Kimberly L
University at Albany, State University of New York, USA.
East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina, USA.
Read Res Q. 2020 Sep;55(Suppl 1):S19-S34. doi: 10.1002/rrq.335. Epub 2020 Sep 16.
Recently, there has been growing concern about how to most effectively support the literacy development of beginning and struggling readers with regard to helping them learn to effortlessly identify the huge number of words that proficient readers ultimately learn to read with automaticity. Some, noting the critical importance of phonics instruction in learning to read in an alphabetic writing system, take the position that students should attend only to alphabetic information in word-solving attempts. However, long-standing theories of the development of word-reading skills support the value of teaching students to use both alphabetic and contextual information in word solving in interactive and confirmatory ways. The authors summarize 25 years of research in which beginning and struggling readers were taught to use both code- and meaning/context-based strategies for word solving and were provided with explicit, responsive instruction focused on the alphabetic code. The authors present brief summaries of theoretical explanations of the word-learning process. Then, the authors summarize six experimental studies that, together, included students in kindergarten through fourth grade and involved the implementation of the Interactive Strategies Approach in the primary grades and an extension of the approach with middle elementary students with reading difficulties. The studies resulted in substantially improved reading outcomes among treatment versus business-as-usual groups. The authors contend that using both phonics- and context-based information facilitates the ability to build sight vocabulary, which in turn enables readers to turn their attention to the most important goal of literacy learning: meaning construction.
最近,人们越来越关注如何最有效地支持初读者和阅读困难者的读写能力发展,以帮助他们学会轻松识别大量单词,而熟练读者最终能够自动阅读这些单词。一些人注意到语音教学法在字母书写系统中学习阅读的至关重要性,认为学生在尝试解决单词问题时应只关注字母信息。然而,长期以来的单词阅读技能发展理论支持这样一种观点,即教学生以交互和验证的方式在解决单词问题时同时使用字母和上下文信息是有价值的。作者总结了25年的研究,在这些研究中,初读者和阅读困难者被教导使用基于代码和基于意义/上下文的策略来解决单词问题,并获得了专注于字母代码的明确、有针对性的指导。作者简要总结了单词学习过程的理论解释。然后,作者总结了六项实验研究,这些研究总共涵盖了从幼儿园到四年级的学生,涉及在小学低年级实施交互式策略方法,并将该方法扩展到有阅读困难的中年级小学生。研究结果表明,与常规教学组相比,实验组的阅读成绩有了显著提高。作者认为,同时使用基于语音和基于上下文的信息有助于建立视觉词汇量,这反过来又使读者能够将注意力转向读写能力学习的最重要目标:意义构建。