Faculty of Odontology, Malmo University, Malmo, Sweden.
Trinity College Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2021 Dec;49(6):581-593. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.12630. Epub 2021 Mar 8.
Global sustainability is considered the number one health concern facing our planet. Dental care is currently not provided in a sustainable way. This study aims to quantify the potential environmental burden of an examination in a hypothetical dental practice and identify major contributors to environmental harm.
A life cycle analysis was performed for the life cycle of an examination of one patient in a hypothetical dental practice. The equipment and products analysed were those available at the Faculty of Dentistry, Malmö University. The Ecoinvent version 3.5 database and the life cycle assessment software tool OpenLCA version 1.10 were chosen for this study.
Normalized results indicate that the impact categories to which the modelled examination most significantly contributes are water scarcity, freshwater eutrophication and human toxicity (cancer effects). The major contributors or hotspots relating to the environmental harm of an examination procedure are soaps and detergents, disposable bibs, surface disinfection, stainless-steel instruments, clothing, water use and wastewater.
Normalized results indicate that the potential environmental impact of an examination compared to one individual's impact per year is minimal. Considering the potential number of dental examinations and other dental procedures performed every year puts the findings in another perspective. This paper touches on some of the ways that the environmental burden of an examination could be reduced. Small changes to everyday practice, such as always making sure the dishwasher and washing machines are full when turned on, using less environmentally damaging soaps, more sustainable clothing alternatives and using necessary instruments could significantly reduce dentistry's environmental impact. Changes in materials and practice may result in potential trade-offs. Research would need to be carried out comparing the environmental burden of any alternatives. We hope in the near future that there will be more evidence relating to products used within dental care settings, potential trade-offs and dentistry's environmental burden.
全球可持续性被认为是我们星球面临的头号健康问题。牙科护理目前没有以可持续的方式提供。本研究旨在量化一个假设牙科诊所检查的潜在环境负担,并确定对环境危害的主要贡献者。
对假设牙科诊所中一名患者检查的生命周期进行了生命周期分析。分析的设备和产品是马尔默大学牙科学院提供的。本研究选择了 Ecoinvent 版本 3.5 数据库和生命周期评估软件工具 OpenLCA 版本 1.10。
归一化结果表明,模型检查对水短缺、淡水富营养化和人类毒性(癌症效应)等影响类别贡献最大。与检查程序的环境危害相关的主要贡献者或热点是肥皂和洗涤剂、一次性围兜、表面消毒、不锈钢仪器、衣物、水的使用和废水。
归一化结果表明,与个人每年的影响相比,检查的潜在环境影响微不足道。考虑到每年进行的牙科检查和其他牙科程序的潜在数量,研究结果就会呈现出另一个角度。本文探讨了一些减少检查环境负担的方法。日常实践中的一些小改变,例如确保洗碗机和洗衣机在打开时装满、使用对环境破坏较小的肥皂、更可持续的服装替代品以及使用必要的仪器,都可以显著减少牙科的环境影响。材料和实践的变化可能会导致潜在的权衡。需要进行研究,比较任何替代品的环境负担。我们希望在不久的将来,会有更多关于牙科护理环境中使用的产品、潜在的权衡以及牙科的环境负担的证据。