Shilt Jeffrey, McHorse Grant, Moisiuc Alexis, Kushare Indranil
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Texas Children's Hospital, 17580 Interstate 45 South, The Woodlands, TX, 77384, USA.
Baylor College of Medicine, 1 Baylor Plaza, Houston, TX, 77030, USA.
J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2021 Jan;12(1):172-176. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2020.06.030. Epub 2020 Jun 23.
Surgical treatment for avulsion injuries of the proximal hamstrings has gained increasing popularity over the past decade. Despite good outcomes, early failures have been noted and have been attributed to slipping and falling, postoperative muscle spasm, or early mobilization. In a recent review of hamstring repair rehabilitation protocols, it was shown that there is marked variability in post-operative management. Post-operative bracing with limiting knee extension and hip flexion is the standard of care in most early rehabilitation protocols. Braces with limitation of hip flexion and knee locked in 90 flexion can be awkward, cumbersome and create fall risk.Chemoprotection has more recently been proposed to be an alternative approach to prevent tendon repair failure and controlled mobilization which has been shown to be superior to complete immobilization. We present the first case series of the use of botulinum toxin for chemo-protection of the proximal hamstring ischial avulsion repair, demonstrating its safety and efficacy.
Retrospective case series at a tertiary children's hospital which included patients <18 years of age who underwent interventional treatment for proximal hamstring avulsion injuries of the ischium utilizing botulinum toxin as a chemoprotective agent. Data collected included demographic data, injury and treatment details, imaging, post-operative rehabilitation and return to activity. Descriptive statistical analysis was conducted.
Five male patients with mean age 14 years (12-17) were included in the study. All were sports related non-contact injuries. Radiographs showed displaced avulsion fractures in all 5 patients. All patients had failed conservative management initially; mean time to surgery from initial injury was 34.4 weeks. 4 patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), 1 patient with less displacement had bone marrow aspirate (BMA) injection; all had chemoprotection using botulinum toxin injected in the hamstrings. No patient required hip immobilization or knee immobilization locked to 90°. We elected to use a brace locked at 20° knee flexion in 2/5 patients. All patients underwent supervised physical therapy and achieved symmetric knee range of motion (ROM). Post-operative radiographs confirmed healing of the avulsion fracture in all 5 patients and they all returned to previous level of activity at mean 32 weeks (21-43) from surgery. None of the patients had a hamstring re-injury at mean follow up of 27 months (11-42).
Our case series is the first in literature that shows the safety and efficacy of chemoprotection with botulinum toxin for the post-operative management of avulsion injuries of proximal hamstrings, by minimizing the need for cumbersome bracing and allowing controlled motion during physical therapy.
在过去十年中,近端腘绳肌撕脱伤的手术治疗越来越受到欢迎。尽管治疗效果良好,但仍有早期失败的病例,原因包括滑倒、术后肌肉痉挛或过早活动。在最近一篇关于腘绳肌修复康复方案的综述中,发现术后管理存在显著差异。在大多数早期康复方案中,限制膝关节伸展和髋关节屈曲的术后支具固定是标准治疗方法。限制髋关节屈曲且膝关节锁定在90度屈曲位的支具可能会让人感到笨拙、不便,并增加跌倒风险。最近有人提出化学保护是一种预防肌腱修复失败的替代方法,而控制性活动已被证明优于完全固定。我们展示了首例使用肉毒杆菌毒素对近端腘绳肌坐骨支撕脱伤进行化学保护的病例系列,证明了其安全性和有效性。
在一家三级儿童医院进行的回顾性病例系列研究,纳入了年龄小于18岁、采用肉毒杆菌毒素作为化学保护剂对近端腘绳肌坐骨支撕脱伤进行介入治疗的患者。收集的数据包括人口统计学数据、损伤和治疗细节、影像学检查、术后康复及恢复活动情况。进行了描述性统计分析。
该研究纳入了5名男性患者,平均年龄14岁(12 - 17岁)。所有损伤均与运动相关且为非接触性损伤。X线片显示所有5名患者均有移位的撕脱骨折。所有患者最初保守治疗均失败;从初次受伤到手术的平均时间为34.4周。4例患者接受了切开复位内固定(ORIF),1例移位较小的患者接受了骨髓抽吸(BMA)注射;所有患者均在腘绳肌注射肉毒杆菌毒素进行化学保护。没有患者需要髋关节固定或膝关节锁定在90度固定。我们选择在2/5的患者中使用锁定在膝关节屈曲20度的支具固定。所有患者均接受了有监督的物理治疗,并实现了双侧膝关节活动范围(ROM)对称。术后X线片证实所有5例患者的撕脱骨折均愈合,他们均在术后平均32周(21 - 43周)恢复到之前的活动水平。在平均27个月(11 - 42个月)的随访中,没有患者出现腘绳肌再次损伤。
我们的病例系列是文献中首例表明肉毒杆菌毒素化学保护对近端腘绳肌撕脱伤术后管理具有安全性和有效性的研究,通过减少对笨重支具的需求并在物理治疗期间允许控制性活动来实现。