Agüera-Ortiz Luis, García-Ramos Rocío, Grandas Pérez Francisco J, López-Álvarez Jorge, Montes Rodríguez José Manuel, Olazarán Rodríguez F Javier, Olivera Pueyo Javier, Pelegrin Valero Carmelo, Porta-Etessam Jesús
Service of Psychiatry, Instituto de Investigación i+12, Hospital Universitario 12 de Octubre, Madrid, Spain.
Centro de Investigación Biomédica en Red de Salud Mental (CIBERSAM), Madrid, Spain.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Feb 26;12:638651. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.638651. eCollection 2021.
Alzheimer's disease (AD) and other forms of dementia are among the most common causes of disability in the elderly. Dementia is often accompanied by depression, but specific diagnostic criteria and treatment approaches are still lacking. This study aimed to gather expert opinions on dementia and depressed patient management to reduce heterogeneity in everyday practice. Prospective, multicenter, 2-round Modified Delphi survey with 53 questions regarding risk factors (11), signs and symptoms (7), diagnosis (8), and treatment (27) of depression in dementia, with a particular focus on AD. The questionnaire was completed by a panel of 37 expert physicians in neurodegenerative diseases (19 neurologists, 17 psychiatrists, and 1 geriatrician). Consensus was achieved in 40 (75.5%) of the items: agreement in 33 (62.3%) and disagreement in 7 (13.2%) of them. Among the most relevant findings, depression in the elderly was considered an early sign (prodromal) and/or a dementia risk factor, so routine cognitive check-ups in depressed patients should be adopted, aided by clinical scales and information from relatives. Careful interpretation of neuropsychological assessment must be carried out in patients with depression as it can undermine cognitive outcomes. As agreed, depression in early AD is characterized by somatic symptoms and can be differentiated from apathy by the presence of sadness, depressive thoughts and early-morning awakening. In later-phases, symptoms of depression would include sleep-wake cycle reversal, aggressive behavior, and agitation. Regardless of the stage of dementia, depression would accelerate its course, whereas antidepressants would have the opposite effect. Those that improve cognitive function and/or have a dual or multimodal mode of action were preferred: Duloxetine, venlafaxine/desvenlafaxine, vortioxetine, tianeptine, and mirtazapine. Although antidepressants may be less effective than in cognitively healthy patients, neither dosage nor treatment duration should differ. Anti-dementia cholinesterase inhibitors may have a synergistic effect with antidepressants. Exercise and psychological interventions should not be applied alone before any pharmacological treatment, yet they do play a part in improving depressive symptoms in demented patients. This study sheds light on several unresolved clinical challenges regarding depression in dementia patients. Further studies and specific recommendations for this comorbid patient population are still needed.
阿尔茨海默病(AD)和其他形式的痴呆症是老年人残疾的最常见原因之一。痴呆症常伴有抑郁症,但仍缺乏具体的诊断标准和治疗方法。本研究旨在收集关于痴呆症和抑郁症患者管理的专家意见,以减少日常实践中的异质性。针对痴呆症(尤其是AD)患者抑郁症的危险因素(11项)、体征和症状(7项)、诊断(8项)及治疗(27项),开展了一项前瞻性、多中心、两轮的改良德尔菲调查,共53个问题。问卷由37名神经退行性疾病专家医生组成的小组完成(19名神经科医生、17名精神科医生和1名老年病科医生)。40项(75.5%)条目达成了共识:其中33项(62.3%)达成一致,7项(13.2%)存在分歧。在最相关的研究结果中,老年人的抑郁症被认为是一种早期迹象(前驱症状)和/或痴呆症的危险因素,因此应通过临床量表和亲属提供的信息,对抑郁症患者进行常规认知检查。对于抑郁症患者,必须对神经心理学评估结果进行仔细解读,因为这可能会影响认知结果。大家一致认为,早期AD患者的抑郁症以躯体症状为特征,可通过悲伤、抑郁情绪和早醒与淡漠相鉴别。在疾病后期,抑郁症的症状包括睡眠 - 觉醒周期颠倒、攻击行为和激越。无论痴呆症处于哪个阶段,抑郁症都会加速其病程发展,而抗抑郁药则有相反的作用。那些能改善认知功能和/或具有双重或多模式作用机制的药物更受青睐:度洛西汀、文拉法辛/去甲文拉法辛、伏硫西汀、噻奈普汀和米氮平。尽管抗抑郁药在痴呆症患者中的疗效可能不如认知功能正常的患者,但剂量和治疗持续时间均不应有差异。抗痴呆胆碱酯酶抑制剂可能与抗抑郁药产生协同作用。在进行任何药物治疗之前,运动和心理干预不应单独应用,但它们确实有助于改善痴呆症患者的抑郁症状。本研究揭示了痴呆症患者抑郁症方面几个尚未解决的临床挑战。仍需要针对这一合并症患者群体开展进一步研究并提出具体建议。