School of Civil Engineering, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangdong, 510275, China.
School of Public Health (Shenzhen), Sun Yat-sen University, Guangdong, 510275, China.
Environ Pollut. 2021 Jun 1;278:116832. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2021.116832. Epub 2021 Mar 1.
To evaluate pesticide regulatory standards in agricultural crops, we introduced a regulatory modeling framework that can flexibly evaluate a population's aggregate exposure risk via maximum residue levels (MRLs) under good agricultural practice (GAP). Based on the structure of the aggregate exposure model and the nature of variable distributions, we optimized the framework to achieve a simplified mathematical expression based on lognormal variables including the lognormal sum approximation and lognormal product theorem. The proposed model was validated using Monte Carlo simulation, which demonstrates a good match for both head and tail ends of the distribution (e.g., the maximum error = 2.01% at the 99th percentile). In comparison with the point estimate approach (i.e., theoretical maximum daily intake, TMDI), the proposed model produced higher simulated daily intake (SDI) values based on empirical and precautionary assumptions. For example, the values at the 75th percentile of the SDI distributions simulated from the European Union (EU) MRLs of 13 common pesticides in 12 common crops were equal to the estimated TMDI values, and the SDI values at the 99th percentile were over 1.6-times the corresponding TMDI values. Furthermore, the model was refined by incorporating the lognormal distributions of biometric variables (i.e., food intake rate, processing factor, and body weight) and varying the unit-to-unit variability factor (VF) of the pesticide residues in crops. This ensures that our proposed model is flexible across a broad spectrum of pesticide residues. Overall, our results show that the SDI is significantly reduced, which may better reflect reality. In addition, using a point estimate or lognormal PF distribution is effective as risk assessments typically focus on the upper end of the distribution.
为了评估农业作物中的农药监管标准,我们引入了一个监管建模框架,该框架可以通过良好农业规范(GAP)下的最大残留限量(MRL)灵活评估人群的总体暴露风险。基于综合暴露模型的结构和变量分布的性质,我们对框架进行了优化,以实现基于对数正态变量的简化数学表达式,包括对数正态和逼近和对数正态乘积定理。通过蒙特卡罗模拟验证了所提出的模型,该模型在分布的首尾(例如,99 百分位数的最大误差=2.01%)都具有很好的匹配性。与点估计方法(即理论最大日摄入量,TMDI)相比,基于经验和预防假设,所提出的模型产生了更高的模拟日摄入量(SDI)值。例如,在欧盟(EU)12 种常见作物中 13 种常见农药的 MRL 模拟的 SDI 分布的第 75 百分位数的值等于估计的 TMDI 值,而 SDI 分布的第 99 百分位数的值超过相应 TMDI 值的 1.6 倍。此外,通过纳入生物计量变量(即食物摄入量、加工因子和体重)的对数正态分布以及变化作物中农药残留的单位间变异性因子(VF),对模型进行了细化。这确保了我们提出的模型在广泛的农药残留范围内具有灵活性。总体而言,我们的结果表明 SDI 显著降低,这可能更能反映现实。此外,使用点估计或对数正态 PF 分布是有效的,因为风险评估通常侧重于分布的上限。