Radford J A, Cowan R A, Flanagan M, Dunn G, Crowther D, Johnson R J, Eddleston B
CRC Department of Medical Oncology, Christie Hospital, Manchester, United Kingdom.
J Clin Oncol. 1988 Jun;6(6):940-6. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1988.6.6.940.
The chest radiographs (CXRs) of 110 patients with mediastinal Hodgkin's disease (HD) were reviewed to determine the incidence, degree, and significance of mediastinal abnormalities following treatment. Residual mediastinal abnormalities were defined as either minimal or measurable, and occurred in 64% of all patients at the completion of treatment, but were more common in those with bulky mediastinal disease at presentation (40 of 48, 83%). Fifty-one patients with a mediastinal abnormality at the end of treatment had follow-up films available. Partial or complete regression of the abnormality occurred by 1 year in 30 of these patients (59%). Over a median follow-up of 80.5 months, there were more relapses (13 of 70, 19%) in patients with residual abnormalities following treatment than in those where the mediastinum was considered normal (four of 40, 10%). Measurable abnormality was associated with a higher relapse rate (six of 25, 24%) than minimal abnormality (seven of 45, 16%), but none of these differences were statistically significant. the subsequent relapse rate for patients with persisting abnormality at 1 year was 14%, compared with 17% for patients in whom regression had occurred and 14% in whom the mediastinum had always been considered normal. Considering the whole group, the presence of a mediastinal abnormality following treatment did not predict for relapse, but for the 34 patients treated by chemotherapy (CTR) alone, a residual abnormality was associated with a significantly higher relapse rate (P = .029). We conclude that following mediastinal radiotherapy (XRT) administered either alone or combined with CTR, residual mediastinal abnormalities do not indicate the need for further treatment. However, following CTR alone, such abnormalities may signify persisting disease and we recommend that XRT be considered for these patients.
对110例纵隔霍奇金病(HD)患者的胸部X线片(CXR)进行了回顾,以确定治疗后纵隔异常的发生率、程度及意义。残留纵隔异常被定义为轻微或可测量的异常,在所有患者治疗结束时发生率为64%,但在初诊时纵隔病变较大的患者中更常见(48例中的40例,83%)。治疗结束时存在纵隔异常的51例患者有随访胸片。这些患者中有30例(59%)在1年内异常部分或完全消退。在中位随访80.5个月期间,治疗后有残留异常的患者复发率(70例中的13例,19%)高于纵隔被认为正常的患者(40例中的4例,10%)。可测量的异常比轻微异常的复发率更高(25例中的6例,24%比45例中的7例,16%),但这些差异均无统计学意义。1年后持续存在异常的患者后续复发率为14%,相比之下,异常已消退的患者为17%,纵隔一直被认为正常的患者为14%。就整个组而言,治疗后纵隔异常的存在并不能预测复发,但对于仅接受化疗(CTR)的34例患者,残留异常与显著更高的复发率相关(P = 0.029)。我们得出结论,在单独或联合CTR进行纵隔放疗(XRT)后,残留纵隔异常并不表明需要进一步治疗。然而,仅接受CTR后,此类异常可能意味着疾病持续存在,我们建议对这些患者考虑进行XRT。