Department of Pediatric Cardiac Center, Beijing Anzhen Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
J Card Surg. 2021 Jul;36(7):2197-2203. doi: 10.1111/jocs.15500. Epub 2021 Mar 22.
It is very important to accurately assess the transannular patch (TAP) in the surgical treatment of tetralogy of Fallot (TOF). The pulmonary annulus index (PAI; the actual pulmonary annulus diameter divided by the expected pulmonary annulus diameter), GA ratio (the ratio of pulmonary annulus and aortic annulus), PAAI (the ratio of pulmonary annulus cross-section and aortic annulus cross-section), and pulmonary annulus Z score (PA Z score) were compared. This study aimed to analyze and explore the application value of PAI in predicting the need for TAP in children undergoing TOF repair.
In total, 130 patients who were diagnosed with TOF and underwent TOF repair in Beijing Anzhen Hospital affiliated to Capital Medical University from December 2018 to December 2019 were retrospectively studied. In total, 112 cases were included in this study and 18 cases were excluded, of which 16 cases were aged above 18 years and 2 cases suffered from Down syndrome. They were divided into TAP group and no TAP group; the values of the pulmonary annulus and aortic annulus were measured. GA ratio, PAI, PAAI, the pulmonary annulus Z score, and main pulmonary artery (MPA) Z score were calculated to perform statistical analysis.
A total of 112 patients were included in the study, aged 4-177 months, with an average of 22.87 ± 30.21 months; 66 males and 46 females; weighing 5.3-29 kg, with an average of 9.94 ± 4.08 kg; three cases died, one case died of sepsis caused by pulmonary infection, one case died of low cardiac output syndrome, and one case died of multiple organ failure. In total, 62 cases (55.8%) did not undergo TAP and 50 cases (44.2%) underwent TAP. The pulmonary annulus Z score, main pulmonary artery Z score, and PAI in the TAP group were smaller than those in the no TAP group (p < .05). Receiver operating curve (ROC) analysis showed that when the cut-off value of pulmonary annulus was -1.98, the area under the curve (AUC) was 0.88, the sensitivity was 80%, and the specificity was 71%; when the cut-off value of PAI was 0.53, AUC was 0.85, the sensitivity was 75%, and the specificity was 80%; when the cut-off value of GA ratio was 0.55, AUC was 0.85, the sensitivity was 76%, and the specificity was 80%. The area under the PAAI curve was 0.85, the sensitivity was 76%, and the specificity was 79%. When the pulmonary valve Z score, PAI, GA ratio, PAAI, and MPA Z score were all greater than the dividing value, TAP was avoided in more than 90% of children with TOF. When the pulmonary valve Z score, PAI, GA ratio, PAAI, and the main pulmonary artery Z score were all below the dividing value, more than 90% of children with TOF needed TAP.
The predictive effect of PAI as a simple and effective predictor of TAP in TOF radical operation is the same as that of pulmonary annulus Z score, and combining it with the main pulmonary artery Z score was the most accurate method of prediction.
准确评估法洛四联症(TOF)根治术中的跨环补片(TAP)非常重要。本研究旨在分析和探讨肺瓣环指数(PAI;实际肺瓣环直径与预期肺瓣环直径的比值)、GA 比值(肺瓣环与主动脉瓣环的比值)、PAAI(肺瓣环横截面积与主动脉瓣环横截面积的比值)和肺瓣环 Z 评分(PAZ 评分)在预测 TOF 患儿行 TAP 修补术的必要性中的应用价值。
回顾性分析 2018 年 12 月至 2019 年 12 月首都医科大学附属北京安贞医院收治的 130 例 TOF 患儿的临床资料。其中 112 例患儿纳入本研究,18 例患儿被排除(16 例患儿年龄大于 18 岁,2 例患儿患有唐氏综合征),分为 TAP 组和无 TAP 组;测量肺瓣环和主动脉瓣环的直径,计算 GA 比值、PAI、PAAI、PAZ 评分和主肺动脉 Z 评分,进行统计学分析。
本研究共纳入 112 例患儿,年龄 4-177 个月,平均年龄 22.87±30.21 个月;男 66 例,女 46 例;体质量 5.3-29kg,平均体质量 9.94±4.08kg;3 例患儿死亡,其中 1 例因肺部感染引起脓毒症死亡,1 例因低心排综合征死亡,1 例因多器官功能衰竭死亡。无 TAP 修补术组 62 例(55.8%),行 TAP 修补术组 50 例(44.2%)。TAP 组患儿的 PAZ 评分、主肺动脉 Z 评分和 PAI 均小于无 TAP 组(P<.05)。受试者工作特征曲线(ROC)分析显示,当肺瓣环截断值为-1.98 时,曲线下面积(AUC)为 0.88,灵敏度为 80%,特异度为 71%;当 PAI 截断值为 0.53 时,AUC 为 0.85,灵敏度为 75%,特异度为 80%;当 GA 比值截断值为 0.55 时,AUC 为 0.85,灵敏度为 76%,特异度为 80%。PAAI 曲线下面积为 0.85,灵敏度为 76%,特异度为 79%。当肺动脉瓣 Z 评分、PAI、GA 比值、PAAI 和主肺动脉 Z 评分均大于截断值时,TOF 患儿中超过 90%可以避免 TAP。当肺动脉瓣 Z 评分、PAI、GA 比值、PAAI 和主肺动脉 Z 评分均小于截断值时,TOF 患儿中超过 90%需要 TAP。
PAI 作为一种简单有效的 TOF 根治术中 TAP 预测指标,与肺瓣环 Z 评分预测效果相同,与主肺动脉 Z 评分联合应用预测效果最准确。