Dermatology and Venereology Department, Faculty of Medicine (for Girls), Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.
J Cosmet Dermatol. 2022 Feb;21(2):707-715. doi: 10.1111/jocd.14090. Epub 2021 Apr 8.
Multiple therapeutic modalities are available for alopecia areata (AA) but still a challenging disease with variable severity, recurrence, and a major cosmetic concern.
Compare the effectiveness and safety of intralesional methotrexate (MTX) versus triamcinolone acetonide (TrA) in the treatment of localized AA in adults, both clinically and trichoscopically.
PATIENTS/METHODS: 40 adult patients with localized AA were recruited and divided into two groups. 20 patients were treated by intralesional TrA and the other 20 patients were treated by intralesional MTX every 3 weeks, for maximum four sessions. Clinical and trichoscopic evaluation at baseline, each session and for 3 months after the last session was performed.
At the end of sessions (12 weeks), regrowth scale was significantly higher in TrA group compared to MTX group (p-value = 0.028). But, after 3-month follow-up, regrowth scale was higher in MTX group compared to TrA group (p-value = 0.153). A statistically significant reduction in AA specific trichoscopic signs after 12 weeks and at the 3-month follow-up in both groups. Local adverse events in both groups were transient and disappeared during the follow-up period.
Intralesional MTX in treatment of localized AA in adults can be promising and comparable to intralesional TrA with the need for further controlled and extensive trials. Trichoscopy can reveal early clinical response through disappearance of AA-specific trichoscopic signs and also early detection of adverse effects.
斑秃(AA)有多种治疗方法,但仍是一种具有不同严重程度、复发率和主要美容问题的挑战性疾病。
比较局部注射甲氨蝶呤(MTX)与曲安奈德(TrA)治疗成人局限性 AA 的疗效和安全性,包括临床和毛发镜检查。
患者/方法:招募了 40 名成人局限性 AA 患者,并将其分为两组。20 名患者接受局部注射 TrA,另 20 名患者接受每 3 周一次的局部注射 MTX,最多进行四次治疗。在基线、每次治疗和最后一次治疗后 3 个月进行临床和毛发镜评估。
在治疗结束时(12 周),TrA 组的再生评分明显高于 MTX 组(p 值=0.028)。但是,在 3 个月的随访中,MTX 组的再生评分高于 TrA 组(p 值=0.153)。两组在 12 周和 3 个月随访时,AA 特定毛发镜特征均有显著减少。两组的局部不良反应均为短暂性的,在随访期间消失。
局部注射 MTX 治疗成人局限性 AA 可能是一种有前途的方法,与局部注射 TrA 相当,需要进一步进行对照和广泛的临床试验。毛发镜检查可以通过 AA 特定毛发镜特征的消失来显示早期临床反应,也可以早期发现不良反应。