Department of Psychology, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, UK.
Department of Psychology, Lancaster University, Lancaster, United Kingdom.
Memory. 2021 Apr;29(4):471-485. doi: 10.1080/09658211.2021.1903508. Epub 2021 Mar 24.
Reports about repeated experiences tend to include more schematic information than information about specific instances. However, investigators in both forensic and intelligence settings typically seek specific over general information. We tested a multi-method interviewing format (MMIF) to facilitate recall and particularisation of repeated events through the use of the self-generated cues mnemonic, the timeline technique, and follow-up questions. Over separate sessions, 150 adult participants watched four scripted films depicting a series of meetings in which a terrorist group planned attacks and planted explosive devices. For half of our sample, the third witnessed event included two deviations (one new detail and one changed detail). A week later, participants provided their account using the MMIF, the timeline technique with self-generated cues, or a free recall format followed by open-ended questions. As expected, more information was reported overall in the MMIF condition compared to the other format conditions, for two types of details, correct details, and correct gist details. The reporting of internal intrusions was comparable across format conditions. Contrary to hypotheses, the presence of deviations did not benefit recall or source monitoring. Our findings have implications for information elicitation in applied settings and for future research on adults' retrieval of repeated events.
关于重复体验的报告往往包含更多的图式信息,而不是关于具体实例的信息。然而,法医和情报机构的调查人员通常都希望获得具体而非一般的信息。我们测试了一种多方法访谈格式(MMIF),通过使用自我生成线索助记符、时间线技术和后续问题来促进重复事件的回忆和具体化。在单独的会话中,150 名成年参与者观看了四部脚本电影,这些电影描述了一个恐怖组织策划袭击和安置爆炸装置的一系列会议。对于我们样本的一半参与者来说,第三个目击事件包含两个偏差(一个新细节和一个更改的细节)。一周后,参与者使用 MMIF、带有自我生成线索的时间线技术或自由回忆格式以及开放式问题提供他们的陈述。正如预期的那样,与其他格式条件相比,MMIF 条件下总体上报告了更多的信息,包括两种类型的细节,正确的细节和正确的主旨细节。格式条件之间的内部干扰报告相似。与假设相反,偏差的存在并没有促进回忆或来源监测。我们的发现对应用环境中的信息收集以及对成年人重复事件检索的未来研究具有影响。