Substance Abuse Prevention Research Centre, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran.
Iranian National Center for Addiction Studies (INCAS), Iranian Institute for Reduction of High-Risk Behaviors, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Int J Legal Med. 2021 Jul;135(4):1515-1524. doi: 10.1007/s00414-020-02475-x. Epub 2021 Mar 30.
Elder abuse continues to be a taboo, mostly underestimated, ignored by societies across the world. Recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses have revealed significant variations in the prevalence of elder abuse, with large geographic variations. This is the first study that compares the prevalence of elder abuse and risk factors between a European and Asian countries and using the same method. Cross-sectional surveys were conducted in Spain and Iran. Eight hundred forty subjects, aged 65 and over, were chosen randomly from patients in primary care health centres. Prevalence of abuse and subtypes and risk factors were obtained using structured interviews. To minimize the potential effects of selection bias, a propensity score matching was performed. Multiple correspondence analysis was used to evaluate the possible relationships among all the variables and to identify specific profiles. Five hundred thirty-two older people remained for the analysis after matching. The prevalence of abuse was 39.1% in Spain and 80.5% in Iran. Elder abuse and its subtypes are significantly more probable in Iran than in Spain. Out of every five elderly people questioned, two in Spain and four in Iran responded affirmatively to a question concerning elder abuse. Multiple correspondence analysis allows the differences between patterns of elder abuse between both populations to be visualized. Elder abuse is a prevalent problem in Spain and Iran. While some characteristics are shared in the pattern of abuse there are different profiles between the two countries. Detecting elder abuse should be a priority objective in clinical and forensic setting. Key points • This is the first study that compares the prevalence of elder abuse between a European and Asian country, using the same methodology. • Multiple correspondence analysis allows specific elder abuse profiles to be identified. • Elder abuse is significantly more likely to occur in Iran than in Spain. • Out of every five elderly people questioned, two in Spain and four in Iran responded affirmatively to a question concerning elder abuse.
虐待老人仍然是一个禁忌话题,在世界范围内,这种现象大多被低估和忽视。最近的系统评价和荟萃分析显示,虐待老人的发生率存在显著差异,且存在较大的地域差异。这是第一项比较欧洲和亚洲国家虐待老人发生率和危险因素的研究,并使用了相同的方法。在西班牙和伊朗进行了横断面调查。从初级保健中心的患者中随机选择了 844 名年龄在 65 岁及以上的受试者。使用结构化访谈获得虐待和亚型的发生率以及危险因素。为了最大限度地减少选择偏差的潜在影响,进行了倾向评分匹配。多元对应分析用于评估所有变量之间可能存在的关系,并确定特定的模式。匹配后,有 532 名老年人保留进行分析。西班牙的虐待发生率为 39.1%,伊朗为 80.5%。伊朗的虐待和亚型发生率明显高于西班牙。在被询问的每 5 位老年人中,西班牙有 2 位,伊朗有 4 位肯定回答了关于虐待老人的问题。多元对应分析可以直观地显示两个群体之间虐待老人模式的差异。虐待老人在西班牙和伊朗都是一个普遍存在的问题。虽然在虐待模式上存在一些共同特征,但两国之间存在不同的模式。在临床和法医环境中,应该将发现虐待老人作为一个优先目标。关键点 • 这是第一项比较欧洲和亚洲国家之间虐待老人发生率的研究,使用了相同的方法。 • 多元对应分析可以确定特定的虐待老人模式。 • 与西班牙相比,伊朗更有可能发生虐待老人的情况。 • 在被询问的每 5 位老年人中,西班牙有 2 位,伊朗有 4 位肯定回答了关于虐待老人的问题。