Technological and Higher Education Institute of Hong Kong (THEi), Chai Wan, Hong Kong.
PLoS One. 2021 Apr 2;16(4):e0249423. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0249423. eCollection 2021.
Despite the wide adoption of emergency remote learning (ERL) in higher education during the COVID-19 pandemic, there is insufficient understanding of influencing factors predicting student satisfaction for this novel learning environment in crisis. The present study investigated important predictors in determining the satisfaction of undergraduate students (N = 425) from multiple departments in using ERL at a self-funded university in Hong Kong while Moodle and Microsoft Team are the key learning tools. By comparing the predictive accuracy between multiple regression and machine learning models before and after the use of random forest recursive feature elimination, all multiple regression, and machine learning models showed improved accuracy while the most accurate model was the elastic net regression with 65.2% explained variance. The results show only neutral (4.11 on a 7-point Likert scale) regarding the overall satisfaction score on ERL. Even majority of students are competent in technology and have no obvious issue in accessing learning devices or Wi-Fi, face-to-face learning is more preferable compared to ERL and this is found to be the most important predictor. Besides, the level of efforts made by instructors, the agreement on the appropriateness of the adjusted assessment methods, and the perception of online learning being well delivered are shown to be highly important in determining the satisfaction scores. The results suggest that the need of reviewing the quality and quantity of modified assessment accommodated for ERL and structured class delivery with the suitable amount of interactive learning according to the learning culture and program nature.
尽管在 COVID-19 大流行期间,高等教育广泛采用了紧急远程学习 (ERL),但对于这种危机中新的学习环境,人们对预测学生满意度的影响因素了解不足。本研究调查了香港一所自筹资金大学的多个系本科生(N=425)在使用 Moodle 和 Microsoft Team 等关键学习工具时,影响其对 ERL 满意度的重要预测因素。通过比较使用随机森林递归特征消除前后多元回归和机器学习模型的预测准确性,所有多元回归和机器学习模型的准确性都有所提高,而最准确的模型是弹性网络回归,解释方差为 65.2%。结果表明,学生对 ERL 的整体满意度仅为中性(7 分制中的 4.11 分)。即使大多数学生都具备技术能力,并且在访问学习设备或 Wi-Fi 方面没有明显问题,但与 ERL 相比,面对面学习更受欢迎,这被发现是最重要的预测因素。此外,教师所付出的努力程度、对调整评估方法的适当性的认同以及对在线学习交付情况的看法,都被证明对确定满意度得分非常重要。研究结果表明,需要根据学习文化和项目性质,审查 ERL 以及根据适当的互动学习量进行结构化课堂教学的质量和数量,以及修改后的评估方法。