Texeira da Silva Luis Eduardo Carelli, Khan Ahsan Ali, Campos de Barros Alderico Girão, Krywinski Fernando Miguel, Cabral de Araujo Fagundes Fabio Antonio, de Souza E Silva Felipe Gomes
Department of Spine Surgery, National Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Department of Complex and Minimal Invasive Spine Surgery, Spine Institute of Rio de Janeiro (INCOL), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
J Craniovertebr Junction Spine. 2020 Oct-Dec;11(4):321-330. doi: 10.4103/jcvjs.JCVJS_172_20. Epub 2020 Nov 26.
The objective of this study is to propose a novel classification and algorithmic-based management plan for craniovertebral junction osteoarthrosis (CVJOA).
A retrospective study was done based on prospective database of radiological studies and clinical history. Twenty symptomatic patients (12 females and 8 males) with a mean age of 54.8 years were identified with CVJOA. These patients underwent either nonsurgical treatment only or surgical intervention and had follow-up of at least 14 months. Classification of CVJOA is based on coronal deformity, rigidity, stability, and two modifiers. The main surgical procedures done in the surgical arm of these patients included C1-C2 fusion, C1-C2 facet distraction and fusion, and unilateral subaxial facet distraction, and posterior column osteotomy.
All the twenty patients included in this study complained of either sub-occipital or upper neck pain and had radiological evidence of CVJOA. Seven patients improved with nonsurgical management and 13 underwent surgical intervention. Surgical recommendations for each type of CVJOA have been described with case examples, and algorithm for the management of CVJOA has been developed based on this study. Interobserver agreement on CVJOA classification was measured using kappa value statistics which showed moderate strength of agreement (0.467).
This study describes a novel classification and management of CVJOA based on algorithm and current surgical recommendations for each type of CVJOA.
本研究的目的是为颅颈交界区骨关节炎(CVJOA)提出一种基于分类和算法的新型管理方案。
基于放射学研究和临床病史的前瞻性数据库进行回顾性研究。确定了20例有症状的CVJOA患者(12名女性和8名男性),平均年龄54.8岁。这些患者要么仅接受非手术治疗,要么接受手术干预,且随访至少14个月。CVJOA的分类基于冠状面畸形、僵硬程度、稳定性以及两个修正因素。这些患者手术组所进行的主要手术包括C1-C2融合术、C1-C2小关节撑开融合术、单侧下颈椎小关节撑开术以及后路截骨术。
本研究纳入的所有20例患者均主诉枕下或上颈部疼痛,且有CVJOA的影像学证据。7例患者通过非手术治疗得到改善,13例接受了手术干预。已通过病例示例描述了每种类型CVJOA的手术建议,并基于本研究制定了CVJOA的管理算法。使用kappa值统计量测量了观察者间对CVJOA分类 的一致性,结果显示一致性强度为中等(0.467)。
本研究描述了一种基于算法以及针对每种类型CVJOA的当前手术建议的CVJOA新型分类和管理方法。