Connolly Florian, Alsolivany Joan, Czabanka Marcus, Vajkoczy Peter, Valdueza Jose M, Röhl Jens E, Siebert Eberhard, Danyel Leon A
Departments of1Neurology and.
2Neurosurgery, University Hospital Charité, Berlin.
J Neurosurg. 2021 Apr 9;135(6):1666-1673. doi: 10.3171/2020.9.JNS202709. Print 2021 Dec 1.
Superficial temporal artery-middle cerebral artery (STA-MCA) bypass surgery is an important therapy for symptomatic moyamoya disease. Its success depends on bypass function, which may be impaired by primary or secondary bypass insufficiency. Catheter angiography is the current gold standard to assess bypass function, whereas the diagnostic value of ultrasonography (US) has not been systematically analyzed so far.
The authors analyzed 50 STA-MCA bypasses in 39 patients (age 45 ± 14 years [mean ± SD]; 26 female, 13 male). Bypass patency was evaluated by catheter angiography, which was performed within 24 hours after US. The collateral circulation through the bypass was classified into 4 types as follows: the bypass supplies more than two-thirds (type A); between one-third and two-thirds (type B); or less than one-third (type C) of the MCA territory; or there is bypass occlusion (type D). The authors assessed the mean blood flow velocity (BFV), the blood volume flow (BVF), and the pulsatility index (PI) in the external carotid artery and STA by duplex sonography. Additionally, they analyzed the flow direction of the MCA by transcranial color-coded sonography. US findings were compared between bypasses with higher (types A and B) and lower (types C and D) capacity.
Catheter angiography revealed high STA-MCA bypass capacity in 35 cases (type A: n = 22, type B: n = 13), whereas low bypass capacity was noted in the remaining 15 cases (type C: n = 12, type D: n = 3). The BVF values in the STA were 60 ± 28 ml/min (range 4-121 ml/min) in the former and 12 ± 4 ml/min (range 6-18 ml/min) in the latter group (p < 0.0001). Corresponding values of mean BFV and PI were 57 ± 21 cm/sec (range 16-100 cm/sec) versus 22 ± 8 cm/sec (range 10-38 cm/sec) (p < 0.0001) and 0.8 ± 0.2 (range 0.4-1.3) versus 1.4 ± 0.5 (range 0.5-2.4) (p < 0.0001), respectively. Differences in the external carotid artery were less distinct: BVF 217 ± 71 ml/min (range 110-425 ml/min) versus 151 ± 41 ml/min (range 87-229 ml/min) (p = 0.001); mean BFV 47 ± 17 cm/sec (range 24-108 cm/sec) versus 40 ± 7 cm/sec (range 26-50 cm/sec) (p = 0.15); PI 1.5 ± 0.4 (range 1.0-2.5) versus 1.9 ± 0.4 (range 1.2-2.6) (p = 0.009). A retrograde blood flow in the MCA was found in 14 cases (9 in the M1 and M2 segment; 5 in the M2 segment alone), and all of them showed a good bypass function (type A, n = 10; type B, n = 4). The best parameter (cutoff value) to distinguish bypasses with higher capacity from bypasses with lower capacity was a BVF in the STA ≥ 21 ml/min (sensitivity 100%, negative predictive value 100%, specificity 91%, positive predictive value 83%).
Duplex sonography is a suitable diagnostic tool to assess STA-MCA bypass function in moyamoya disease. Hemodynamic monitoring of the STA by US provides an excellent predictor of bypass patency.
颞浅动脉-大脑中动脉(STA-MCA)搭桥手术是有症状烟雾病的重要治疗方法。其成功取决于搭桥功能,而原发性或继发性搭桥不足可能会损害该功能。导管血管造影是评估搭桥功能的当前金标准,而超声检查(US)的诊断价值迄今尚未得到系统分析。
作者分析了39例患者(年龄45±14岁[均值±标准差];女性26例,男性13例)的50例STA-MCA搭桥手术。通过导管血管造影评估搭桥通畅情况,该检查在超声检查后24小时内进行。通过搭桥的侧支循环分为以下4种类型:搭桥供应超过三分之二的大脑中动脉区域(A型);供应三分之一至三分之二(B型);或供应少于三分之一(C型);或存在搭桥闭塞(D型)。作者通过双功超声评估颈外动脉和颞浅动脉的平均血流速度(BFV)、血容量流量(BVF)和搏动指数(PI)。此外,他们通过经颅彩色编码超声分析大脑中动脉的血流方向。比较了高容量(A型和B型)和低容量(C型和D型)搭桥的超声检查结果。
导管血管造影显示35例STA-MCA搭桥容量高(A型:n = 22,B型:n = 13),其余15例搭桥容量低(C型:n = 12,D型:n = 3)。前一组颞浅动脉的血容量流量值为60±28 ml/分钟(范围4 - 121 ml/分钟),后一组为12±4 ml/分钟(范围6 - 18 ml/分钟)(p < 0.0001)。平均血流速度和搏动指数的相应值分别为57±21 cm/秒(范围16 - 100 cm/秒)对22±8 cm/秒(范围10 - 38 cm/秒)(p < 0.0001)和0.8±0.2(范围0.4 - 1.3)对1.4±0.5(范围0.5 - 2.4)(p < 0.0001)。颈外动脉的差异不太明显:血容量流量217±71 ml/分钟(范围110 - 425 ml/分钟)对151±41 ml/分钟(范围87 - 229 ml/分钟)(p = 0.001);平均血流速度为47±l7 cm/秒(范围2A - 108 cm/秒)对40±7 cm/秒(范围26 - 50 cm/秒)(p = 0.15);搏动指数1.5±0.4(范围1.0 - 2.5)对1.9±0.4(范围1.2 - 2.6)(p = 0.009)。14例大脑中动脉出现逆行血流(M1和M2段9例;仅M2段5例),所有这些病例均显示搭桥功能良好(A型,n = 10;B型,n = 4)。区分高容量搭桥和低容量搭桥的最佳参数(临界值)是颞浅动脉血容量流量≥21 ml/分钟(敏感性100%,阴性预测值100%,特异性91%,阳性预测值83%)。
双功超声是评估烟雾病中STA-MCA搭桥功能的合适诊断工具。通过超声对颞浅动脉进行血流动力学监测可很好地预测搭桥通畅情况。