Soprovich Allison L, Bottorff Joan L, Wozniak Lisa A, Oliffe John L, Seaton Cherisse L, Duncan Mitch J, Caperchione Cristina M, Ellehoj Elizabeth R, Johnson Steven T
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Institute for Healthy Living and Chronic Disease Prevention; School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada.
Behav Sleep Med. 2022 Mar-Apr;20(2):224-240. doi: 10.1080/15402002.2021.1909594. Epub 2021 Apr 12.
The purpose of this qualitative study was to explore working men's perspectives about sleep health and the intersecting influences of gender and work, describing participant's views on current and potential programming and organizational support to promote sleep health.
Twenty men employed in male-dominated industries in the north-central region of Alberta, Canada, participated in 4 consultation group discussions addressing motivators, facilitators and barriers to sleep health.
Participants reported sleeping an average of 6.36 (SD ±1.1) hours per night, and the majority worked more than 40 hours per week. Data were analyzed using an inductive approach. The findings provided important insights. In normalizing sleep deprivation and prioritizing the need to "just keep going" on six or less hours of sleep, the men subscribed to masculine ideals related to workplace perseverance, stamina and resilience. Workplace cultures and practices were implicated including normative dimensions of overtime and high productivity and output, amid masculine cultures constraining emotions and conversations about sleep, the sum of which muted avenues for discussing, let alone promoting sleep. Challenges to good sleep were primarily constructed around time constraints, and worry about meeting work and home responsibilities. Men's preferences for workplace support included providing and incentivizing the use of sleep health resources, designing work for sleep health (e.g., shift schedules, overtime policies) and getting advice from experienced coworkers and experts external to the workplace organization.
These findings hold potential for informing future gender-sensitive programming and organizational practices to support sleep health among working men.
本定性研究旨在探讨职业男性对睡眠健康的看法以及性别与工作的交叉影响,描述参与者对当前及潜在的促进睡眠健康的项目和组织支持的看法。
20名受雇于加拿大艾伯塔省中北部男性主导行业的男性参与了4次咨询小组讨论,内容涉及睡眠健康的激励因素、促进因素和障碍。
参与者报告平均每晚睡眠6.36(标准差±1.1)小时,大多数人每周工作超过40小时。采用归纳法对数据进行分析。研究结果提供了重要见解。在将睡眠不足常态化并优先考虑在6小时或更少睡眠时间下“坚持下去”的必要性时,这些男性认同与职场毅力、耐力和恢复力相关的男性理想。职场文化和做法受到牵连,包括加班以及高生产率和产出的规范层面,在抑制情绪和关于睡眠的对话的男性文化中,这些因素加起来使讨论睡眠的途径变得沉默,更不用说促进睡眠了。良好睡眠面临的挑战主要围绕时间限制以及担心无法履行工作和家庭责任。男性对职场支持的偏好包括提供并激励使用睡眠健康资源、为睡眠健康设计工作(如轮班安排、加班政策)以及从职场组织外部的经验丰富的同事和专家那里获取建议。
这些研究结果有可能为未来支持职业男性睡眠健康的性别敏感型项目和组织实践提供信息。