Forsyth School of Dental Hygiene, MCPHS University and Clinical Dental Hygienist, East Side Periodontics and Implantology, Inc., Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
Forsyth School of Dental Hygiene, MCPHS University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2021 Aug;85(8):1340-1348. doi: 10.1002/jdd.12612. Epub 2021 Apr 12.
PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: There is little research regarding dental hygiene faculty perspectives on advising graduate students through the thesis process. This study explored dental hygiene faculty's experiences when advising DH graduate students through the thesis process and understanding their perspectives on the factors impacting completion of the thesis.
This qualitative phenomenological research study utilized virtual focus groups with a purposive sample of graduate DH thesis advisors (n = 18) from institutions with a thesis-based Master of Science degree. A deductive analysis method was implemented based on six main topics (advisor's roles, advisor expectations of advisee, advisee challenges, student support strategies, institutional polices and resources, and academic workload and benefits of the advisor role) in the literature using qualitative analysis software.
Main emergent themes included being a co-investigator and supervisor of the advisee research process; expectations of advisee to respect the advisor's time and effort; expectation advisee understand the demands of a thesis; advisees challenges included self-doubt and balancing of responsibilities; need to develop the advisor/advisee relationship and trust with advisee; and university policies and the availability of resources impact on the thesis completion.
Dental Hygiene thesis advisors reported incorporation of many strategies to execute their role. The thesis process is unique to every student; however, the advisor's comprehensive problem-solving skills and the student's perseverance collectively facilitate the completion of the thesis. Institutional policies, other resources, and the increase in workload are potential barriers for Dental Hygiene thesis advisors and require advocating on behalf of their advisee for on-time thesis completion.
目的/目标:关于牙科卫生教师在指导研究生完成论文过程中的观点的研究很少。本研究探讨了牙科卫生教师在指导 DH 研究生完成论文过程中的经验,并了解他们对影响论文完成的因素的看法。
这项定性现象学研究使用虚拟焦点小组,对具有基于论文的理科硕士学位的机构中的 18 名研究生 DH 论文顾问(n=18)进行了有目的的抽样。采用基于文献的六个主要主题(顾问的角色、顾问对被指导者的期望、被指导者的挑战、学生支持策略、机构政策和资源以及学术工作量和顾问角色的好处)的演绎分析方法,并使用定性分析软件进行分析。
主要的新兴主题包括作为被指导者研究过程的共同研究者和导师;期望被指导者尊重顾问的时间和努力;期望被指导者理解论文的要求;被指导者的挑战包括自我怀疑和平衡责任;需要与被指导者发展顾问/被指导者关系并建立信任;以及大学政策和资源的可用性对论文完成的影响。
牙科卫生论文顾问报告说,他们采用了许多策略来执行他们的角色。论文过程对每个学生都是独特的;然而,顾问的综合解决问题的能力和学生的毅力共同促进了论文的完成。机构政策、其他资源和工作量的增加是牙科卫生论文顾问的潜在障碍,需要代表他们的被指导者争取按时完成论文。