University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Department of Surgery, Center for Surgical Training and Research, Michigan Medicine, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
J Surg Res. 2024 Jan;293:670-675. doi: 10.1016/j.jss.2023.09.005. Epub 2023 Oct 13.
Given the rapidly changing landscape of residency applications, many medical students struggle to identify guidance from faculty advisors. Additionally, faculty advisors may find it difficult to maintain up-to-date knowledge on changes such as the new supplemental application. These gaps could potentially lead to inequitable advising. The objective of this study was to identify both students' and faculty's perceived barriers and expectations for residency application advising.
Anonymous surveys were administered to both fourth-year medical students and faculty advisors at a single institution within 2 mo of the residency application deadline. Survey questions assessed student and faculty barriers to establishing the advisor-advisee relationships, as well as expectations of the advisor role. Surveys were analyzed using descriptive statistics.
We identified that the majority of students (57%) did not have a faculty advisor within weeks of the application deadline, and an equal amount felt that finding an advisor was either somewhat difficult or extremely difficult. Of all the students, 60% felt their biggest barrier was not knowing how to find an advisor. Though faculty felt equipped to advise students, 75% of faculty in the participating specialties had advising concerns regarding the supplemental application or were unaware of the changes.
We identified gaps in the residency application advising process from both student and faculty perspectives. Future work involves increasing awareness of the resources and opportunities available to students to improve advising relationships. Standardized training tools and resources for faculty will result in more consistent and reliable faculty advising.
鉴于住院医师申请的快速变化,许多医学生难以从教师顾问那里获得指导。此外,教师顾问可能难以跟上新补充申请等变化的最新知识。这些差距可能导致咨询的不平等。本研究的目的是确定学生和教师对住院医师申请咨询的感知障碍和期望。
在住院医师申请截止日期后的 2 个月内,对一家机构的四年级医学生和教师顾问进行了匿名调查。调查问题评估了学生和教师在建立顾问-被顾问关系方面的障碍,以及对顾问角色的期望。使用描述性统计分析调查结果。
我们发现,大多数学生(57%)在申请截止日期后的几周内没有教师顾问,并且同样有一半的学生认为找到顾问有些困难或非常困难。在所有学生中,60%的人认为他们最大的障碍是不知道如何找到顾问。尽管教师认为自己有能力为学生提供建议,但参与专业的 75%的教师对补充申请存在担忧,或者不了解这些变化。
我们从学生和教师的角度发现了住院医师申请咨询过程中的差距。未来的工作涉及提高学生对可用资源和机会的认识,以改善咨询关系。为教师提供标准化的培训工具和资源将导致更一致和可靠的教师咨询。