IAS-Research - Centre for Life, Mind and Society. Philosophy Department, University of the Basque Country, San Sebastián, Spain.
Facultad de Educación, Filosofía y Antropología, Universidad del País Vasco, Avenida de Tolosa 70, 20018, San Sebastián, Guipúzcoa, Spain.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2021 Apr 14;43(2):57. doi: 10.1007/s40656-021-00373-y.
This body of work is motivated by an apparent contradiction between, on the one hand, Darwin's testimony in his autobiographical text about a supposed perceptual colour blindness before the aesthetic magnificence of natural landscapes, and, on the other hand, the last paragraph of On the Origin of Species, where he claims to perceive the forms of nature as beautiful and wonderful. My aim is to delve into the essence of the Darwinian perception of beauty in the context of the Weberian concept of "disenchantment of the world", assumed as a possible conceptual axis that enables the unravelling of the core of this contrast of perceptions. In acknowledging the theory of evolution as one of the most prominent scientific theories likely to have contributed to disenchantment, a number of questions arise: Is disenchantment compatible with aesthetic experience and sensibility before natural beauty? Was it Darwin's disenchanted conception of the world that led him to believe he was colour blind? To answer these questions, a computer-assisted semantic analysis of lexical frequency and variability, most especially focused on aesthetic-emotional and religious or spiritual adverbs and adjectives, has been undertaken across the six editions of The Origin. The semantic analysis demonstrates that, although disenchanted, Darwin's descriptions of, mainly, the adaptational excellence of living beings, reflect an aesthetically enriched perception of nature. It is concluded that Darwin's perceptual colour blindness, then, might be based on a confusion rooted in the equation of equality between aesthetic sensibility in nature and the perception of its beauty as part of the vestigia Dei.
这项工作的动机是达尔文在自传体文本中所描述的一种明显的矛盾,一方面是他在自然景观的美学壮丽之前,据称存在感知色觉障碍,另一方面是他在《物种起源》的最后一段中声称,他将自然形式视为美丽和奇妙的。我的目的是在韦伯的“世界祛魅”概念的背景下深入探讨达尔文对美的感知的本质,该概念被假定为一个可能的概念轴,能够揭示这种感知对比的核心。在承认进化论是最有可能促成祛魅的突出科学理论之一的同时,出现了一些问题:祛魅是否与自然美之前的审美体验和感性兼容?是达尔文对世界的祛魅观念导致他相信自己是色盲吗?为了回答这些问题,我们对《物种起源》的六个版本进行了计算机辅助的词汇频率和可变性的语义分析,特别关注美学情感和宗教或精神副词和形容词。语义分析表明,尽管达尔文的描述被祛魅了,但他对生物适应卓越性的描述,反映了对自然的审美丰富的感知。因此,达尔文的感知色盲可能是基于一种混淆,即自然中的审美感性与将其视为上帝遗迹的一部分的美感感知相等同。