Department of Medicine, College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, USA.
Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, USA.
Dis Esophagus. 2021 Sep 9;34(9). doi: 10.1093/dote/doab019.
Symptom severity and prevalence of erosive disease in gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) differ between genders. It is not known how gastroenterologists incorporate patient gender in their decision-making process. We aimed to evaluate how gender influences the diagnosis and management recommendations for patients with GERD. We invited a nationwide sample of gastroenterologists via voluntary listservs to complete an online survey of fictional patient scenarios presenting with different GERD symptoms and endoscopic findings. Patient gender for each case was randomly generated. Study participants were asked for their likelihood of a diagnosis of GERD and subsequent management recommendations. Results were analyzed using chi-square tests, Fisher Exact tests, and multivariable logistic regression. Of 819 survey invitations sent, 135 gastroenterologists responded with 95.6% completion rate. There was no significant association between patient gender and prediction for the likelihood of GERD for any of the five clinical scenarios when analyzed separately or when all survey responses were pooled. There was also no significant association between gender and decision to refer for fundoplication, escalate PPI therapy, or start of neuromodulation/behavioral therapy. Despite documented symptomatic and physiologic differences of GERD between the genders, patient gender did not affect respondents' estimates of GERD diagnosis or subsequent management. Further outcomes studies should validate whether response to GERD treatment strategies differ between women and men.
胃食管反流病(GERD)患者的症状严重程度和侵蚀性疾病的患病率存在性别差异。目前尚不清楚胃肠病学家如何将患者的性别纳入其决策过程中。我们旨在评估性别如何影响 GERD 患者的诊断和管理建议。我们通过自愿名单向全国范围内的胃肠病学家发出邀请,要求他们完成一项关于不同 GERD 症状和内镜检查结果的虚构患者病例的在线调查。每个病例的患者性别都是随机生成的。研究参与者被要求评估 GERD 的可能性诊断以及随后的管理建议。使用卡方检验、Fisher 精确检验和多变量逻辑回归分析结果。在发出的 819 份调查邀请中,有 135 名胃肠病学家做出了回应,完成率为 95.6%。当分别分析五个临床情况或汇总所有调查回复时,患者性别与 GERD 可能性预测之间没有显著关联。性别与决定进行胃底折叠术、升级 PPI 治疗或开始神经调节/行为治疗之间也没有显著关联。尽管有文件证明 GERD 在性别之间存在症状和生理差异,但患者性别并未影响受访者对 GERD 诊断或后续管理的估计。进一步的结果研究应该验证 GERD 治疗策略在女性和男性之间的反应是否存在差异。