Habukawa Chizu, Ohgami Naoto, Arai Takahiko, Makata Haruyuki, Tomikawa Morimitsu, Fujino Tokihiko, Manabe Tetsuharu, Ogihara Yoshihito, Ohtani Kiyotaka, Shirao Kenichiro, Sugai Kazuko, Asai Kei, Sato Tetsuya, Murakami Katsumi
Department of Pediatrics, Minami Wakayama Medical Center, Tanabe, Japan.
Omron Healthcare Co, Ltd, Muko, Japan.
JMIR Pediatr Parent. 2021 Jun 17;4(2):e28865. doi: 10.2196/28865.
Since 2020, peoples' lifestyles have been largely changed due to the COVID-19 pandemic worldwide. In the medical field, although many patients prefer remote medical care, this prevents the physician from examining the patient directly; thus, it is important for patients to accurately convey their condition to the physician. Accordingly, remote medical care should be implemented and adaptable home medical devices are required. However, only a few highly accurate home medical devices are available for automatic wheeze detection as an exacerbation sign.
We developed a new handy home medical device with an automatic wheeze recognition algorithm, which is available for clinical use in noisy environments such as a pediatric consultation room or at home. Moreover, the examination time is only 30 seconds, since young children cannot endure a long examination time without crying or moving. The aim of this study was to validate the developed automatic wheeze recognition algorithm as a clinical medical device in children at different institutions.
A total of 374 children aged 4-107 months in pediatric consultation rooms of 10 institutions were enrolled in this study. All participants aged ≥6 years were diagnosed with bronchial asthma and patients ≤5 years had reported at least three episodes of wheezes. Wheezes were detected by auscultation with a stethoscope and recorded for 30 seconds using the wheeze recognition algorithm device (HWZ-1000T) developed based on wheeze characteristics following the Computerized Respiratory Sound Analysis guideline, where the dominant frequency and duration of a wheeze were >100 Hz and >100 ms, respectively. Files containing recorded lung sounds were assessed by each specialist physician and divided into two groups: 177 designated as "wheeze" files and 197 as "no-wheeze" files. Wheeze recognitions were compared between specialist physicians who recorded lung sounds and those recorded using the wheeze recognition algorithm. We calculated the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for all recorded sound files, and evaluated the influence of age and sex on the wheeze detection sensitivity.
Detection of wheezes was not influenced by age and sex. In all files, wheezes were differentiated from noise using the wheeze recognition algorithm. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of the wheeze recognition algorithm were 96.6%, 98.5%, 98.3%, and 97.0%, respectively. Wheezes were automatically detected, and heartbeat sounds, voices, and crying were automatically identified as no-wheeze sounds by the wheeze recognition algorithm.
The wheeze recognition algorithm was verified to identify wheezing with high accuracy; therefore, it might be useful in the practical implementation of asthma management at home. Only a few home medical devices are available for automatic wheeze detection. The wheeze recognition algorithm was verified to identify wheezing with high accuracy and will be useful for wheezing management at home and in remote medical care.
自2020年以来,由于全球新冠疫情,人们的生活方式发生了很大变化。在医疗领域,尽管许多患者更喜欢远程医疗,但这使得医生无法直接检查患者;因此,患者向医生准确传达自身病情很重要。相应地,应实施远程医疗并需要适用的家用医疗设备。然而,用于自动检测哮鸣音作为病情加重迹象的高精度家用医疗设备却很少。
我们开发了一种带有自动哮鸣音识别算法的新型便捷家用医疗设备,可用于儿科诊室或家中等嘈杂环境的临床使用。此外,检查时间仅为30秒,因为幼儿无法长时间忍受检查而不哭闹或乱动。本研究的目的是在不同机构中验证所开发的自动哮鸣音识别算法作为儿童临床医疗设备的有效性。
本研究纳入了10家机构儿科诊室的374名4至107个月大的儿童。所有年龄≥6岁的参与者均被诊断为支气管哮喘,年龄≤5岁的患者报告至少有三次哮鸣发作。使用听诊器听诊检测哮鸣音,并使用基于哮鸣音特征开发的哮鸣音识别算法设备(HWZ - 1000T)按照计算机化呼吸音分析指南记录30秒,其中哮鸣音的主频和持续时间分别>100 Hz和>100 ms。每位专科医生对包含记录的肺音文件进行评估,并分为两组:177个指定为“哮鸣音”文件,197个为“无哮鸣音”文件。比较记录肺音的专科医生与使用哮鸣音识别算法记录的结果之间的哮鸣音识别情况。我们计算了所有记录声音文件的灵敏度、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值,并评估了年龄和性别对哮鸣音检测灵敏度的影响。
哮鸣音的检测不受年龄和性别的影响。在所有文件中,使用哮鸣音识别算法可将哮鸣音与噪音区分开来。哮鸣音识别算法的灵敏度、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为96.6%、98.5%、98.3%和97.0%。哮鸣音被自动检测到,并且心跳声、声音和哭声被哮鸣音识别算法自动识别为无哮鸣音的声音。
哮鸣音识别算法经验证可高精度识别哮鸣音;因此,它可能在家庭哮喘管理的实际应用中有用。用于自动哮鸣音检测的家用医疗设备很少。哮鸣音识别算法经验证可高精度识别哮鸣音,将对家庭和远程医疗中的哮鸣音管理有用。