Catholic Salesian University Center Auxilium - Lins, São Paulo, Brazil.
Federal University of São Carlos-UFSCar, São Carlos/São Paulo, Brazil.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2021 Mar;44(3):244-254. doi: 10.1016/j.jmpt.2020.09.004. Epub 2021 Apr 18.
The objective of this study was to compare the hypoalgesic effects of isolated or combined use of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) and cervical joint manipulation (JM) in asymptomatic participants.
One hundred and forty-four healthy participants aged 18 to 30 years old were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 groups (n = 36 per group): active TENS + active JM, active TENS + placebo JM, placebo TENS + active JM, and placebo TENS + placebo JM. Active or placebo TENS was applied to the dominant forearm. JM was applied to the C6-7 segments. The pressure pain threshold was measured pre- and postintervention and after 20 minutes on the forearm and tibialis anterior of the dominant side.
Segmental hypoalgesia was greater in the group active TENS + active JM compared with active TENS + placebo JM (P = .002), placebo TENS + active JM (P < .0001), and placebo TENS + placebo JM (P < .0001). For the extrasegmental hypoalgesia, active TENS + active JM had greater hypoalgesic effect compared with active TENS + placebo JM (P = .033), placebo TENS + active JM (P = .002), and placebo TENS + placebo JM (P < .0001).
TENS and JM produced hypoalgesia when used alone and, when the treatments were combined, a higher segmental and extrasegmental hypoalgesic effect was obtained in asymptomatic participants.
本研究旨在比较经皮神经电刺激(TENS)和颈椎关节手法(JM)单独或联合使用在无症状参与者中的镇痛效果。
144 名年龄在 18 至 30 岁之间的健康参与者被随机分配到 4 组中的 1 组(每组 36 人):主动 TENS+主动 JM、主动 TENS+安慰剂 JM、安慰剂 TENS+主动 JM 和安慰剂 TENS+安慰剂 JM。主动或安慰剂 TENS 应用于优势前臂。JM 应用于 C6-7 节段。在干预前、干预后以及优势侧前臂和胫骨前肌 20 分钟后测量压力疼痛阈值。
与主动 TENS+安慰剂 JM(P=.002)、安慰剂 TENS+主动 JM(P<.0001)和安慰剂 TENS+安慰剂 JM(P<.0001)相比,主动 TENS+主动 JM 组的节段性镇痛作用更大。对于节外镇痛,主动 TENS+主动 JM 与主动 TENS+安慰剂 JM(P=.033)、安慰剂 TENS+主动 JM(P=.002)和安慰剂 TENS+安慰剂 JM(P<.0001)相比,镇痛效果更大。
TENS 和 JM 单独使用时可产生镇痛作用,当联合使用时,在无症状参与者中可获得更高的节段性和节外镇痛效果。