Gausman Jewel, Othman Areej, Al-Qotob Raeda, Shaheen Abeer, Abu Sabbah Eman, Aldiqs Mohannad, Hamad Iqbal, Dabobe Maysoon, Langer Ana
Department of Global Health and Population, Women & Health Initiative, Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Ave, Boston, MA, 02115, USA.
Department of Maternal and Child Health Nursing, School of Nursing, University of Jordan, Queen Rania Street, Amman, Jordan.
Reprod Health. 2021 Apr 21;18(1):84. doi: 10.1186/s12978-021-01137-4.
Youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health (SRH) services are thought to make such services for adolescents more accessible and acceptable; however, provider attitudes may still present an important barrier. Improving youth SRH service utilization has been recognized as a national priority in Jordan; however, existing services remain underutilized. Previous studies found that youth perceive SRH services to be inadequate and that providers are not supportive of their needs. The purpose of this study is measure provider attitudes towards youth-friendly SRH services and explore their variation according to individual characteristics among health care professionals in Jordan.
We measured provider attitudes towards youth-friendly SRH services using a scale that was developed and validated in Jordan. The scale consists of three subscales: (1) Attitudes towards SRH information and services offered to youth, (2) Norms and personal beliefs, and (3) Attitudes towards the policy and clinical environment. Possible scores range between 1 and 4, with higher scores reflecting more youth-friendly attitudes. Physicians, midwives and nurses working at either primary health centers, comprehensive care centers, or women's and children's health centers where services to adolescents are or should be offered were recruited from four governorates in Jordan using a two-stage, cluster sampling scheme. Differences in attitudes were assessed using simple and multivariable linear regression analysis.
The sample consisted of 510 providers from four governorates in Jordan. The mean provider score on the full scale was 2.7, with a range of 2.0 to 3.8. On Subscales 1 and 2, physicians exhibited significantly more youth-friendly attitudes than nurses by scoring 0.17 points higher than nurses on Subscale 1 (95% CI: 0.02-0.32; p < 0.05) in adjusted analyses. Providers who had been previously trained in SRH issues scored 0.10 points higher (95% CI: 0.00-0.20; p < 0.05) than those who had not on Subscale 3. No differences were found according to provider characteristics on Subscale 2. Providers exhibited the lowest scores related to items referencing youth sexual behavior.
Provider attitudes towards youth-friendly SRH service delivery highlight context-specific, cultural concerns. The limited variation in attitudes related to norms and personal beliefs may be a reflection that such beliefs are deeply held across Jordanian society. Last, as past training on SRH was significantly associated with higher scores, our results suggest opportunity for intervention to improve providers' confidence and knowledge.
青少年友好型性与生殖健康(SRH)服务被认为能使青少年更容易获得并接受此类服务;然而,提供者的态度可能仍是一个重要障碍。提高青少年对SRH服务的利用率已被约旦视为国家优先事项;然而,现有服务的利用率仍然较低。先前的研究发现,青少年认为SRH服务不足,且提供者不支持他们的需求。本研究的目的是衡量医疗保健提供者对青少年友好型SRH服务的态度,并探讨其在约旦医疗保健专业人员中因个人特征的差异。
我们使用在约旦开发并验证的量表来衡量提供者对青少年友好型SRH服务的态度。该量表由三个子量表组成:(1)对向青少年提供的SRH信息和服务的态度,(2)规范和个人信念,以及(3)对政策和临床环境的态度。可能的分数范围在1到4之间,分数越高表明态度越有利于青少年。采用两阶段整群抽样方案,从约旦四个省的初级卫生中心、综合护理中心或妇女和儿童健康中心招募从事青少年服务或应提供此类服务的医生、助产士和护士。使用简单和多变量线性回归分析评估态度差异。
样本包括来自约旦四个省的510名提供者。提供者在整个量表上的平均得分是2.7,范围在2.0到3.8之间。在子量表1和2上,在调整分析中医生表现出比护士更有利于青少年的态度,在子量表1上比护士高0.17分(95%置信区间:0.02 - 0.32;p < 0.05)。以前接受过SRH问题培训的提供者在子量表3上比未接受培训者高0.1分(95%置信区间:0.00 - 0.20;p < 0.05)。在子量表2上,未发现因提供者特征而产生的差异。提供者在涉及青少年性行为的项目上得分最低。
提供者对青少年友好型SRH服务提供的态度凸显了特定背景下的文化问题。与规范和个人信念相关的态度差异有限,这可能反映出这些信念在约旦社会中根深蒂固。最后,由于过去对SRH的培训与更高的分数显著相关,我们的结果表明有进行干预以提高提供者信心和知识的机会。