Brouwer Ambroos, Jin Xuxi, Waldi Aisha Humaira, Verheyen Steven
Department of Psychology, Education and Child Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Post Box 1738, 3000 DR, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Sci Rep. 2021 Apr 21;11(1):8627. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-88139-1.
Older participants who are briefly presented with the 'my wife/mother-in-law' ambiguous figure estimate its age to be higher than young participants do. This finding is thought to be the result of a subconscious social group bias that influences participants' perception of the figure. Because people are better able to recognize similarly aged individuals, young participants are expected to perceive the ambiguous figure as a young woman, while older participants are more likely to recognize an older lady. We replicate the difference in age estimates, but find no relationship between participants' age and their perception of the ambiguous figure. This leads us to conclude that the positive relationship between participants' age and their age estimates of the ambiguous 'my wife/mother-in-law' figure is better explained by the own-age anchor effect, which holds that people use their own age as a yard stick to judge the age of the figure, regardless of whether the young woman or the older lady is perceived. Our results disqualify the original finding as an example of cognitive penetrability: the participants' age biases their judgment of the ambiguous figure, not its perception.
向老年参与者短暂展示“我的妻子/岳母”这一两可图形时,他们对其年龄的估计比年轻参与者更高。这一发现被认为是潜意识社会群体偏见影响参与者对该图形认知的结果。由于人们更善于识别年龄相仿的个体,年轻参与者预计会将这个两可图形视为年轻女性,而老年参与者更有可能识别出一位年长女性。我们重复了年龄估计上的差异,但发现参与者的年龄与其对两可图形的认知之间没有关系。这使我们得出结论,参与者的年龄与其对两可的“我的妻子/岳母”图形的年龄估计之间的正相关关系,用自身年龄锚定效应能更好地解释,即人们以自己的年龄为标准来判断图形的年龄,无论所感知到的是年轻女性还是年长女性。我们的结果排除了最初的发现作为认知可穿透性的一个例子:参与者的年龄影响了他们对两可图形的判断,而非对其的认知。