Boyd Matt, Wilson Nick
Adapt Research Ltd, Reefton, New Zealand.
Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand.
Risk Anal. 2021 Dec;41(12):2266-2285. doi: 10.1111/risa.13735. Epub 2021 Apr 22.
Human civilization is vulnerable to global catastrophic biological threats and existential threats. Policy to mitigate the impact of major biological threats should consider worst-case scenarios. We aimed to strengthen existing research on island refuges as a mitigating mechanism against such threats by considering five additional factors as well as recent literature on catastrophic risks and resilience. We also analyzed the performance of potential refuge islands during early phases the COVID-19 pandemic. Using a composite indicator (scored from 0-1) based on 14 global macroindices, we present analysis supporting Australia (0.71), New Zealand (0.64), and Iceland (0.58) as the leading candidate island nation refuges to safeguard the survival of humanity and a flourishing technological civilization from the threat of a catastrophic pandemic. Data from the COVID-19 pandemic supports this finding where islands have performed relatively well. We discuss the persisting weaknesses of even the best candidate refuges and the growing literature describing what preparations such a refuge should ensure to enhance resilience. Refuge preparations by Australia and New Zealand, in particular, may additionally provide some immunity against winter-inducing catastrophes such as global nuclear war. Existing disaster resilience frameworks such as the Sendai framework could be worded to mandate preventive measures against global catastrophic and existential threats. The issue of island refuges against certain global catastrophic risks should be raised at relevant international political summits.
人类文明易受全球灾难性生物威胁和生存威胁的影响。减轻重大生物威胁影响的政策应考虑最坏情况。我们旨在通过考虑五个额外因素以及近期有关灾难性风险和恢复力的文献,加强现有的关于岛屿避难所作为应对此类威胁的缓解机制的研究。我们还分析了潜在避难岛屿在新冠疫情早期阶段的表现。基于14个全球宏观指标,我们使用一个综合指标(得分从0到1)进行分析,结果表明澳大利亚(0.71)、新西兰(0.64)和冰岛(0.58)是保障人类生存和繁荣的技术文明免受灾难性大流行威胁的主要候选岛屿国家避难所。新冠疫情的数据支持了这一发现,即岛屿的表现相对较好。我们讨论了即使是最佳候选避难所仍然存在的弱点,以及越来越多描述此类避难所应确保哪些准备工作以增强恢复力的文献。特别是澳大利亚和新西兰的避难所准备工作,可能还能提供一定程度的抵御冬季引发的灾难(如全球核战争)的能力。现有的灾害恢复力框架(如仙台框架)可以措辞规定针对全球灾难性和生存威胁的预防措施。应在相关国际政治峰会上提出针对某些全球灾难性风险的岛屿避难所问题。