Whelan Kevin, Jones Nicola
Department of Nutritional Sciences, King's College London, London, UK.
J Hum Nutr Diet. 2022 Apr;35(2):396-405. doi: 10.1111/jhn.12905. Epub 2021 Jun 18.
Fermented foods have been consumed for millennia and commercially-produced variants are now available in the food supply. The present study aimed to investigate the availability, cost, ingredients, nutritional content and on-pack claims of commercially-available fermented foods in the UK.
All products from seven categories of commercially-available fermented foods were systematically identified at eight national supermarket chains in the UK. Data were extracted from manufacturer and retailer websites and were compared between categories using a Kruskal-Wallis test and Fisher's exact test.
In total, 143 fermented foods were identified, with kombucha (41, 28.7%), kefir drinks (32, 22.4%), sauerkraut (22, 15.4%) and kefir yoghurts (21, 14.7%) being most common. The number of products sold at each retailer differed between categories (p = 0.016), and was greatest for kefir drink (median = 7.0, interquartile range [IQR] = 9.0), kombucha (median = 5.5, IQR = 11.5) and kefir yoghurts (median = 5.0, IQR = 8.5). Kombucha (£1.99 per serving) and kefir drinks (£1.26 per serving) were the most expensive fermented foods and sauerkraut (£0.66 per serving) and miso (£0.20 per serving) were the least expensive. Energy, fat, saturated fat, sugar, protein and salt content varied between fermented foods (p < 0.001). Nutrition claims were made on 72 (50.3%) products, the total number of cultures was labelled on 29 (20.3%), specific strains were named on 53 (37.1%) and bacteria-related benefits were promoted on 39 (27.3%) products.
Commercially-produced fermented foods are widely available in the UK but are diverse in their cost, nutritional content, ingredients and use of on-pack claims. Consumers should be aware of these variations given the limited evidence of functional benefits from controlled human trials.
发酵食品已被食用了数千年,现在食品供应中也有商业生产的发酵食品变体。本研究旨在调查英国市售发酵食品的可得性、成本、成分、营养成分以及包装上的声明。
在英国的八家全国性连锁超市中系统识别了七类市售发酵食品的所有产品。数据从制造商和零售商网站提取,并使用Kruskal-Wallis检验和Fisher精确检验在不同类别之间进行比较。
总共识别出143种发酵食品,其中康普茶(41种,28.7%)、开菲尔饮料(32种,22.4%)、德国酸菜(22种,15.4%)和开菲尔酸奶(21种,14.7%)最为常见。每个零售商销售的产品数量在不同类别之间有所不同(p = 0.016),开菲尔饮料(中位数 = 7.0,四分位间距[IQR] = 9.0)、康普茶(中位数 = 5.5,IQR = 11.5)和开菲尔酸奶(中位数 = 5.0,IQR = 8.5)的销售数量最多。康普茶(每份1.99英镑)和开菲尔饮料(每份1.26英镑)是最昂贵的发酵食品,德国酸菜(每份0.66英镑)和味噌(每份0.20英镑)是最便宜的。不同发酵食品的能量、脂肪、饱和脂肪、糖、蛋白质和盐含量各不相同(p < 0.001)。72种(50.3%)产品有营养声明,29种(20.3%)产品标注了培养物总数,53种(37.1%)产品列出了特定菌株,39种(27.3%)产品宣传了与细菌相关的益处。
商业生产的发酵食品在英国广泛可得,但在成本、营养成分、成分以及包装声明的使用方面存在差异。鉴于来自对照人体试验的功能益处证据有限,消费者应了解这些差异。