Mallya Ganeshchandra, Gupta Abhinav, Hantush Mohamed M, Govindaraju Rao S
Lyles School of Civil Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA.
Center for Environmental Solutions and Emergency Response, US EPA, Cincinnati, OH, USA.
Environ Model Softw. 2020 Sep 1;131. doi: 10.1016/j.envsoft.2020.104735.
Despite the plethora of methods available for uncertainty quantification, their use has been limited in the practice of water quality (WQ) modeling. In this paper, a decision support tool (DST) that yields a continuous time series of WQ loads from sparse data using streamflows as predictor variables is presented. The DST estimates uncertainty by analyzing residual errors using a relevance vector machine. To highlight the importance of uncertainty quantification, two applications enabled within the DST are discussed. The DST computes (i) probability distributions of four measures of WQ risk analysis- reliability, resilience, vulnerability, and watershed health- as opposed to single deterministic values and (ii) concentration/load reduction required in a WQ constituent to meet total maximum daily load (TMDL) targets along with the associated risk of failure. Accounting for uncertainty reveals that a deterministic analysis may mislead about the WQ risk and the level of compliance attained with established TMDLs.
尽管有大量方法可用于不确定性量化,但它们在水质(WQ)建模实践中的应用却很有限。本文提出了一种决策支持工具(DST),该工具使用流量作为预测变量,从稀疏数据中生成连续时间序列的WQ负荷。DST通过使用相关向量机分析残差误差来估计不确定性。为突出不确定性量化的重要性,讨论了DST中实现的两个应用。DST计算(i)WQ风险分析的四个指标——可靠性、恢复力、脆弱性和流域健康——的概率分布,而不是单个确定性值,以及(ii)WQ成分中达到总最大日负荷(TMDL)目标所需的浓度/负荷降低量以及相关的失败风险。考虑不确定性表明,确定性分析可能会在WQ风险和既定TMDL的达标水平方面产生误导。