Day Stephanie C, Day Giselle, Keller Michele, Touchett Hilary, Amspoker Amber B, Martin Lindsey, Lindsay Jan A
Houston VA HSR&D Center for Innovations in Quality, Effectiveness and Safety, Michael E. DeBakey Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Houston, TX, USA.
VA South Central Mental Illness Research, Education and Clinical Center, Houston, TX, USA.
Mhealth. 2021 Apr 20;7:24. doi: 10.21037/mhealth.2020.03.02. eCollection 2021.
A national shortage of mental health (MH) professionals leaves more than 90% of rural individuals without adequate access to services each year, troubling because 33% of Veterans Health Administration (VHA) enrollees live in rural areas and rural Veterans have a greater risk of suicide than urban Veterans. Additional barriers such as travel distance and cost, stigma and extreme weather or geography add to challenges of rural Veterans seeking treatment. Although the VHA has addressed this disparity by providing telemental health services, provision of services via traditional hub-and-spoke and/or establishment of regional centers has not fully addressed barriers or resource limitations. Video telehealth to home (VTH) has assisted in better addressing geographic, attitudinal and systematic barriers to in-person care; however, its uptake and implementation have been problematic. This article describes the Personalized Implementation of Video Telehealth for Rural Veterans (PIVOT-R) approach, developed in response to the unique needs of rural veterans.
We developed PIVOT, a flexible implementation strategy that is adaptive to site-specific contexts and different digital innovations and relies on a collaborative relationship between external facilitators, internal facilitators and clinical champions. We used formative evaluation (FE) to gather ongoing information about our quality improvement (QI) implementation approach of VTH. Our FE of PIVOT at rural sites provided insight into adaptations to improve rural implementation. This led to development of PIVOT-R, which explicitly focuses on rural implementation. PIVOT-R, developed from provider and patient feedback plus lessons learned during implementation, focuses on rurality as an important diversity factor and addresses relationship building, engaging the site, assessing context and infrastructure and balancing national expectations with site-level goals. During fiscal year 2018 we partnered with a VHA healthcare system in a Western mountain state to pilot the PIVOT-R approach, again using FE which included quantitative and qualitative data collection to evaluate its impact.
PIVOT-R effectively increased uptake of VTH for MH care at the healthcare system evaluated. In fiscal year 2019 the percentage of Veterans receiving MH care via VTH at the site was 10 times greater than in fiscal year 2018, matching the mean VHA nationwide percentage and increasing by 43.24% by the end of 2019. Veteran feedback supported a positive experience by users.
Inclusion of a comprehensive assessment of the rural system, including infrastructure and resources, greatly improves understanding of a system's specific needs and enables a tailored approach targeting relevant barriers. Our FE suggests the potential of PIVOT-R to increase VTH uptake at other rural locations and reinforces the value of telehealth technology as an important resource for rural sites.
全国心理健康专业人员短缺,导致每年超过90%的农村居民无法获得足够的服务,这令人担忧,因为退伍军人健康管理局(VHA)33%的登记人员居住在农村地区,且农村退伍军人自杀风险高于城市退伍军人。诸如出行距离和成本、耻辱感以及极端天气或地理条件等额外障碍,增加了农村退伍军人寻求治疗的挑战。尽管VHA通过提供远程心理健康服务来解决这种差异,但通过传统的中心辐射模式和/或建立区域中心提供服务并未完全消除障碍或解决资源限制问题。视频远程医疗到家(VTH)有助于更好地消除面对面护理的地理、态度和系统障碍;然而,其采用和实施一直存在问题。本文介绍了针对农村退伍军人的独特需求而开发的农村退伍军人视频远程医疗个性化实施(PIVOT - R)方法。
我们开发了PIVOT,这是一种灵活的实施策略,可适应特定地点的情况和不同的数字创新,并依赖外部促进者、内部促进者和临床倡导者之间的合作关系。我们使用形成性评估(FE)来收集有关我们VTH质量改进(QI)实施方法的持续信息。我们在农村地区对PIVOT进行的FE为改进农村实施的调整提供了见解。这促成了PIVOT - R的开发,它明确侧重于农村实施。PIVOT - R是根据提供者和患者的反馈以及实施过程中的经验教训开发的,将农村性视为一个重要的多样性因素,并涉及关系建立、与机构互动、评估环境和基础设施以及平衡国家期望与机构层面目标。在2018财年,我们与西部山区一个州的VHA医疗系统合作,试点PIVOT - R方法,再次使用FE,包括定量和定性数据收集,以评估其影响。
在评估的医疗系统中,PIVOT - R有效地提高了VTH用于心理健康护理的采用率。在2019财年,该机构通过VTH接受心理健康护理的退伍军人比例比2018财年高出10倍,与全国VHA的平均比例相当,并在2019年底增长了43.24%。退伍军人的反馈支持了用户的积极体验。
纳入对农村系统的全面评估,包括基础设施和资源,极大地增进了对系统特定需求的理解,并能够针对相关障碍采取量身定制的方法。我们的FE表明PIVOT - R有潜力在其他农村地区提高VTH的采用率,并强化了远程医疗技术作为农村地区重要资源的价值。