The Bartlett School of Architecture, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2021 Apr 28;16(4):e0250058. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0250058. eCollection 2021.
The impact of the physical workplace on behaviors and attitudes at work is a much-studied topic. Major research streams over the last decades investigated either satisfaction with offices in relation to physical comfort, or how layout decisions influenced interaction and collaboration in the workplace with a focus on open-plan offices. Rather little is known on the effect a workplace layout (such as its openness) has on perceptions of staff regarding teamwork, focused work and perceived productivity. We aim to close this gap by taking a differential approach which appreciates detailed variations within open-plan offices. Not every corner of an office is the same, so the question arises whether satisfaction with workspace differs depending on where someone is sitting. Bringing results of a staff survey in the UK headquarters of a global technology company together with a detailed analysis of spatial qualities at desks based on isovist and visual field analysis, we find that staff are less likely to rate their workplace environment favorably when they have higher numbers of desks within their own field of vision; and when they are facing away from the room with a relatively larger area behind their back compared to the area surrounding them. Aspects of teamwork that are negatively affected include sharing information with others, as well as team identity and cohesion. Focused work (concentration) and working productively are impacted even more so with the largest effect sizes throughout. These findings highlight the relevance of investigating detailed spatial qualities of micro-locations in workplace layouts. Our results also raise important questions regarding the current popular practice in workplace design of providing large open-plan offices for technology companies.
物理工作场所对工作行为和态度的影响是一个备受研究的课题。过去几十年来,主要的研究方向要么是研究办公室在物理舒适度方面的满意度,要么是研究布局决策如何影响工作场所的互动和协作,重点是开放式办公室。对于工作场所布局(例如开放性)如何影响员工对团队合作、专注工作和感知生产力的看法,我们知之甚少。我们旨在通过采用差异化的方法来弥补这一差距,这种方法可以欣赏开放式办公室内的详细变化。办公室的每个角落都不一样,因此出现了这样一个问题:人们坐在哪里,对工作空间的满意度是否会有所不同。我们将英国一家全球科技公司总部的员工调查结果与基于等视线和视野分析的办公桌空间质量的详细分析结合起来,发现当员工在自己的视野范围内有更多的办公桌时,他们对工作环境的评价就不太可能是有利的;当他们背对房间,与身后相比,周围的相对面积较大时,也是如此。受到负面影响的团队合作方面包括与他人分享信息,以及团队身份和凝聚力。专注工作(注意力集中)和高效工作受到的影响更大,影响程度贯穿始终。这些发现强调了调查工作场所布局中微观位置详细空间质量的重要性。我们的研究结果还提出了关于当前在为科技公司提供大型开放式办公室的工作场所设计流行实践的重要问题。