Peric Aleksandar, Gacesa Dejan, Barac Aleksandra, Peric Aneta
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Military Medical Academy Faculty of Medicine, University of Defence, Belgrade, Serbia.
Ear Nose and Throat Hospital "Doctor Zutic", Belgrade, Serbia.
Turk Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2021 Mar;59(1):33-42. doi: 10.4274/tao.2020.6098. Epub 2021 Mar 26.
To assess the effects and adverse events of preparation Sinulan forte containing extracts of five medicinal plants in comparison to mometasone furoate nasal spray (MFNS) in therapy of acute postviral rhinosinusitis (APRS).
We included 46 APRS patients in this prospective investigation and randomized to two groups. The patients in group 1 (n=23) received MFNS 200 μg two times/day for ten days, and patients in group 2 (n=23) received Sinulan forte, tablets 225 mg per os, two times/day also for ten days. We evaluated the total symptom score (TSS), the separate scores for individual symptoms (nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, postnasal discharge, facial pain, impaired sense of smell), the quality-of-life outcome, and the findings from nasal endoscopy (edema of the nasal mucosa, nasal secretion) prior and after the therapy.
Significantly lower absolute post-treatment scores and better relative improvement were identified for TSS, nasal congestion, facial pain, loss of the sense of smell, edema of the mucosa and nasal secretion in patients receiving herbal preparation (group 2). However, lower absolute post-treatment score and better relative improvement were found for rhinorrhea and postnasal drip in group 1. Clinically important differences were found regarding the TSS and endoscopic findings, with no adverse effects in group 2, but in group 1 two patients had mild nasal bleeding and two had sensation of dryness in the nasal mucosa.
Herbal product Sinulan forte can be a safe and effective treatment for APRS. Our results suggest no adverse events of this herbal preparation in comparison to intranasal corticosteroid spray therapy.
比较含五种药用植物提取物的强力西鲁兰制剂与糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂(MFNS)治疗急性病毒性鼻-鼻窦炎(APRS)的疗效及不良事件。
本前瞻性研究纳入46例APRS患者,随机分为两组。第1组(n = 23)患者每天两次使用200μg MFNS,共10天;第2组(n = 23)患者每天两次口服225mg强力西鲁兰片剂,共10天。我们评估了治疗前后的总症状评分(TSS)、各个症状(鼻塞、流涕、鼻后滴漏、面部疼痛、嗅觉减退)的单独评分、生活质量结果以及鼻内镜检查结果(鼻黏膜水肿、鼻分泌物)。
接受草药制剂治疗的患者(第2组)在TSS、鼻塞、面部疼痛、嗅觉丧失、黏膜水肿和鼻分泌物方面,治疗后绝对评分显著更低,相对改善更好。然而,第1组在流涕和鼻后滴漏方面治疗后绝对评分更低,相对改善更好。在TSS和内镜检查结果方面发现了具有临床意义的差异,第2组无不良事件,但第1组有两名患者出现轻度鼻出血,两名患者有鼻黏膜干燥感。
草药产品强力西鲁兰可为APRS提供安全有效的治疗。我们的结果表明,与鼻内皮质类固醇喷雾疗法相比,这种草药制剂无不良事件。