Morgan S L, Weinsier R L, Boker J R, Brooks C M, Feldman E B, Read M S
Department of Nutrition Sciences, University of Alabama, Birmingham 35294.
J Am Coll Nutr. 1988 Jun;7(3):193-7. doi: 10.1080/07315724.1988.10720236.
It has been documented previously that nutrition knowledge of senior medial students at ten southeastern medical schools varies and is positively correlated with student assessment of the quantity and quality of nutrition education. To determine whether the differences in knowledge are related to the medical educational experience or are simply a reflection of differences in the students' knowledge on entry to medical school, the same examination was administered to entering freshmen at eight of the medical schools. The knowledge scores of freshmen were remarkably homogeneous from school to school (53 +/- 1%, range 51-55%), and nutrition knowledge was significantly higher for seniors than for the freshmen at all schools (mean 69 vs 53%, p less than 0.0001). On the basis of responses to survey items on the examination, the freshman medical students were more inclined than senior students to take a nutrition elective (62 vs 34%, p less than 0.0001), and more freshman rated nutrition as being important to their careers (74 vs 59%, p less than 0.05). These data indicate that 1) entering freshman medical students at the different schools studied have comparable levels of nutrition knowledge and are receptive to nutrition education, and 2) differences in medical training programs most likely explain the previously documented variability in nutrition knowledge of graduating medical students. These findings have important implications for professionals planning curricula for medical-nutrition education.
先前已有文献记载,东南地区十所医学院校高年级医学生的营养知识存在差异,且与学生对营养教育数量和质量的评估呈正相关。为了确定知识差异是与医学教育经历有关,还是仅仅反映了学生入学时营养知识的差异,研究人员对其中八所医学院校的入学新生进行了同样的考试。各学校新生的知识得分非常一致(53±1%,范围为51 - 55%),并且在所有学校中,高年级学生的营养知识得分均显著高于新生(平均为69%对53%,p<0.0001)。根据考试中对调查项目的回答,大一医学生比高年级学生更倾向于选择营养选修课(62%对34%,p<0.0001),并且更多大一学生认为营养对他们的职业很重要(74%对59%,p<0.05)。这些数据表明:1)所研究的不同学校的入学大一医学生具有相当水平的营养知识,并且愿意接受营养教育;2)医学培训项目的差异很可能解释了先前记录的毕业医学生营养知识的变异性。这些发现对规划医学营养教育课程的专业人员具有重要意义。