UNIC-NeuroPSI, Institut des Neurosciences Paris-Saclay, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Gif-sur-Yvette 91190, France
eNeuro. 2021 Apr 30;8(2). doi: 10.1523/ENEURO.0130-21.2021. Print 2021 Mar-Apr.
The recent trend toward an industrialization of brain exploration and the technological prowess of artificial intelligence algorithms and high-performance computing has caught the imagination of the public. These impressive advances are fueling an uncontrolled societal hype, the more amplified, the more "Blue Sky" the claim is. Will we ever be able to simulate a brain ? Will "it" (the digital avatar) be conscious? The Blue Brain Project (BBP) and the European flagship the Human Brain Project (HBP) have surfed on this wave for the past 10 years. Their already significant lifetimes now offer new case studies for neuroscience sociology and epistemology, as the projects mature. Their distinctive "Blue Sky" flavor has been a key feature in securing unprecedented funding (more than one billion Euros) mostly through supranational institutions. The longitudinal analysis of these ventures provides clues to how the neuromyth they propagate sells science, in a scientific world based on an economy of promises.
近年来,大脑探索的工业化趋势以及人工智能算法和高性能计算的技术实力引起了公众的想象。这些令人印象深刻的进展正在推动一种不受控制的社会炒作,炒作的声音越大,声称的内容就越“虚无缥缈”。我们是否能够模拟大脑?“它”(数字替身)是否有意识?过去 10 年来,蓝脑计划(BBP)和欧洲旗舰人类脑计划(HBP)一直乘着这股浪潮。随着项目的成熟,它们已经相当长的生命周期为神经科学社会学和认识论提供了新的案例研究。这些项目独特的“虚无缥缈”的色彩是确保获得前所未有的资金(超过 10 亿欧元)的关键因素,这些资金主要来自超国家机构。对这些风险投资的纵向分析为我们提供了线索,了解它们所传播的神经神话如何在一个基于承诺经济的科学世界中推销科学。