Department of Epidemiology, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, USA; Institute for Interdisciplinary Salivary Bioscience Research, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, USA.
Department of Neurosciences, University of California San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA.
Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2021 Jun;87:32-38. doi: 10.1016/j.parkreldis.2021.04.017. Epub 2021 Apr 28.
To investigate whether plasma NfL levels correlate with clinical symptom severity in premanifest (PM) and manifest HD (HD) individuals, and whether a NfL cut-point could distinguish PM from HD patients with reasonable accuracy.
98 participants (33 control, 26 PM, 39 HD), underwent blood sample collection and clinical assessment, using both UHDRS and non-UHDRS measures, at one academic HD Center. Years to onset (YTO), probability of disease onset in 5 years, and predicted years until 60% onset probability were also calculated. NfL levels were measured using a Meso Scale Discovery assay.
Cohorts differed by age. NfL levels differed significantly across diagnostic groups and were significantly correlated with age. Age-adjusted NfL levels were not correlated with clinical measures in either HD or PM cohorts, but were correlated when cohorts were combined. In PM subjects, NfL levels correlated with YTO, probability of onset in 5 years, and years until 60% onset probability. Using ROC analysis, a NfL cut-point of <53.15 pg/ml distinguished HD from control; <74.84 pg/ml distinguished HD from PM.
These findings implicate plasma NfL as a peripheral prognostic marker for premanifest-HD. Notably, we show that significant correlations between NfL and clinical symptoms are detected only when PM + HD subjects are combined, but not within HD subjects alone. To date, prior studies have investigated the clinical usefulness of NfL exclusively in merged PM + HD cohorts. Our data suggests a biasing of these previous correlations, and hence potentially limited usefulness of plasma NfL in monitoring HD symptom progression, for example, in clinical trials.
研究血浆 NfL 水平是否与前驱期(PM)和显性亨廷顿病(HD)个体的临床症状严重程度相关,以及 NfL 截断值是否可以合理准确地区分 PM 和 HD 患者。
98 名参与者(33 名对照组、26 名 PM 组、39 名 HD 组)在一个学术性 HD 中心进行了血液样本采集和临床评估,同时使用 UHDRS 和非 UHDRS 测量方法。还计算了发病年限(YTO)、5 年内发病的概率以及预测到 60%发病概率的时间。使用 Meso Scale Discovery 测定法测量 NfL 水平。
队列因年龄而异。NfL 水平在不同的诊断组之间存在显著差异,且与年龄显著相关。在 HD 或 PM 队列中,年龄调整后的 NfL 水平与临床测量均不相关,但在合并队列中相关。在 PM 患者中,NfL 水平与 YTO、5 年内发病概率和达到 60%发病概率的时间相关。通过 ROC 分析,NfL 截断值<53.15pg/ml 可将 HD 与对照组区分开来;<74.84pg/ml 可将 HD 与 PM 区分开来。
这些发现表明血浆 NfL 是前驱期 HD 的一种外周预后标志物。值得注意的是,我们发现仅当 PM+HD 受试者合并时,才能检测到 NfL 与临床症状之间的显著相关性,而在 HD 受试者中则不能。迄今为止,先前的研究仅在合并的 PM+HD 队列中研究了 NfL 的临床实用性。我们的数据表明,这些先前的相关性存在偏倚,因此,血浆 NfL 在监测 HD 症状进展方面的潜在作用可能有限,例如在临床试验中。