Kotila L, Lönnqvist J
Department of Psychiatry, Helsinki University, Finland.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1988 Mar;77(3):264-70. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1988.tb05119.x.
Four hundred and twenty-two consecutive hospitalized suicide attempts made by 15-19 year old girls and boys in Helsinki area were investigated. One hundred and twenty suicide attempts were made by 115 boys and 302 by 247 girls. Differences between sex were analyzed. Boys had more severe adaptive problems. Their overall level of functioning was poorer than was that of the girls. Their physical health was not as good as that of the girls. Boys did not carry out more severe suicide attempts as concerns the estimated lethality and intent of the attempt, but their suicide attempts seemed to be connected with more severe physical, mental and social problems. Boys were more susceptible to alcohol provoked suicidal behaviour than girls, and they presented less appealing motives. The outcome of the boys was much worse than the outcome of the girls. Risk ratio for suicide during the 5-year follow-up was 2.0 for boys and 0.55 for girls. Risk ratio concerning violent death was 2.43 for boys and 0.33 for girls. Young male adolescents attempting suicide should be taken very seriously as a risk group for subsequent suicide.
对赫尔辛基地区15至19岁青少年连续发生的422起住院自杀未遂事件进行了调查。其中115名男孩有120次自杀未遂,247名女孩有302次自杀未遂。分析了性别差异。男孩有更严重的适应问题。他们的整体功能水平比女孩差。他们的身体健康不如女孩。就自杀未遂的估计致死率和意图而言,男孩并未实施更严重的自杀未遂行为,但他们的自杀未遂似乎与更严重的身体、心理和社会问题有关。男孩比女孩更容易受到酒精引发的自杀行为影响,而且他们的自杀动机不那么吸引人。男孩的结局比女孩差得多。在5年随访期间,男孩自杀的风险比为2.0,女孩为0.55。关于暴力死亡的风险比,男孩为2.43,女孩为0.33。企图自杀的年轻男性青少年作为后续自杀的风险群体应受到高度重视。