Darroch Francine E, Oliffe John L, Montaner Gabriela Gonzalez, Webb Jessica M
Carleton University, Canada.
University of British Columbia, Canada.
Health (London). 2023 Jan;27(1):147-166. doi: 10.1177/13634593211014275. Epub 2021 May 4.
Physical activity can be a conduit for improving men's social connectedness as well as physical gains for well-being. However, marginalised men, and fathers in particular, can be challenged to engage in leisure time physical activity. This qualitative study reports how fathers, who experience complex and significant social and health inequities, conceptualise and experience barriers to physical activity. Drawing from focus groups with 17 fathers, and semi-structured interviews with seven service providers about their perspectives on men's physical activity in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside (DTES), a highly marginalised neighbourhood. A masculinities framework was used to describe and contextualise physical activity in fathers' lives. Three themes were inductively derived through the analyses: (1) 'they're busy surviving' a finding referencing the work and limits invoked by poverty wherein survival was triaged ahead of leisure time physical activity; (2) 'there is no activity centre' chronicling the lack of physical activity spaces, programmes and resources available to fathers; and (3) 'lifestyle affects our capability to exercise' a theme detailing how social isolation amplified by factors including housing and opioid crises, and being a father in a resource poor setting imposed significant barriers to physical activity. The findings support reconceptualising physical activity programmes with men who are living in marginalising conditions to address behavioural and structural health inequities in tailoring father-centred programmes and resources.
体育活动可以成为改善男性社会联系以及增进幸福感的身体收益的一种途径。然而,被边缘化的男性,尤其是父亲,可能在参与休闲体育活动方面面临挑战。这项定性研究报告了那些经历复杂且重大社会和健康不平等的父亲如何理解和体验体育活动的障碍。该研究基于对17位父亲的焦点小组访谈,以及对7位服务提供者关于他们对温哥华市中心东区(DTES)男性体育活动看法的半结构化访谈,DTES是一个高度边缘化的社区。采用男性气质框架来描述父亲生活中的体育活动并将其置于背景之中。通过分析归纳出三个主题:(1)“他们忙于生存”,这一发现提及了贫困带来的工作和限制,其中生存被置于休闲体育活动之前;(2)“没有活动中心”,记录了父亲们可利用的体育活动空间、项目和资源的匮乏;(3)“生活方式影响我们锻炼的能力”,该主题详细说明了包括住房和阿片类药物危机等因素加剧的社会孤立,以及在资源匮乏环境中身为父亲给体育活动带来的重大障碍。研究结果支持重新构想针对处于边缘化状况男性的体育活动项目,以在制定以父亲为中心的项目和资源时解决行为和结构上的健康不平等问题。