Almohammed Omar A, Alotaibi Lama H, Ibn Malik Shatha A
Department of Clinical Pharmacy, College of Pharmacy, King Saud University, P.O. Box 2457, Riyadh, 11451, Saudi Arabia.
BMC Med Educ. 2021 May 4;21(1):257. doi: 10.1186/s12909-021-02698-5.
The COVID-19 pandemic has required governments around the world to suspend face-to-face learning for school and university students. Colleges of pharmacy are faced with the challenge of training students in hospitals that are under considerable pressure at this time. The government of Saudi Arabia has moved all classes and training online to limit the spread of the virus. This study describes the experience of the Introductory and Advanced Pharmacy Practice Experience (IPPE and APPE) students and preceptors engaged in the virtual IPPE training.
A cross-sectional study was conducted to describe and appraise the implemented virtual IPPE training from the experiences of IPPE and APPE students, and their preceptor. The IPPE students described their experiences in close-ended questionnaires, while APPE students in open-ended questionnaires, and the preceptor described the experiences in narrative. The study focused on highlighting the advantages, opportunities, challenges, and shortcomings of the virtual training.
Two preceptors and seven APPE students participated in the preparation and administration of the virtual training. The IPPE students' experiences, based on 87 respondents, were mostly positive. Although IPPE students enjoyed the time flexibility that allowed the learning of new skills and reflection on previous experiences, 15% experienced difficulty finding quiet places with a reliable internet connection or had difficulty working on team-based activities. Moreover, some were anxious about the lack of adequate patient-care experience. On the other hand, the APPE students found the experience enriching as they gained experience and understanding of academic workflow, gained skills, and overcame the challenges they faced during this virtual training experience.
Future training programs should be organized to overcome the challenges and to maximize the benefits of training experiences. Schools of pharmacy may benefit from the training materials constructed, prepared, and administered by APPE students to improve IPPE students' learning experiences and outcomes.
新冠疫情要求世界各国政府暂停中小学和大学生的面对面学习。药学院面临着在此时承受巨大压力的医院中培训学生的挑战。沙特阿拉伯政府已将所有课程和培训转移到线上,以限制病毒传播。本研究描述了参与虚拟入门药学实践经验(IPPE)培训的IPPE和高级药学实践经验(APPE)学生及带教老师的经历。
开展一项横断面研究,从IPPE和APPE学生及其带教老师的经历来描述和评估所实施的虚拟IPPE培训。IPPE学生通过封闭式问卷描述他们的经历,APPE学生通过开放式问卷描述,带教老师则以叙述形式描述经历。该研究重点突出虚拟培训的优势、机遇、挑战和不足。
两名带教老师和七名APPE学生参与了虚拟培训的准备和管理工作。基于87名受访者的IPPE学生的经历大多是积极的。尽管IPPE学生享受时间灵活性,这使他们能够学习新技能并反思以往经历,但15%的学生在寻找有可靠网络连接的安静场所时遇到困难,或在开展团队活动时遇到困难。此外,一些学生对缺乏足够的患者护理经验感到焦虑。另一方面,APPE学生发现这段经历很充实,因为他们获得了学术工作流程的经验和理解,获得了技能,并克服了在这次虚拟培训经历中所面临的挑战。
应组织未来的培训项目以克服挑战,并使培训经历的益处最大化。药学院可能会受益于由APPE学生构建、准备和管理的培训材料,以改善IPPE学生的学习体验和成果。