Department of Veterinary Medicine, University of Perugia, Via San Costanzo, 4, 06126, Perugia, Italy.
Department of Veterinary Sciences, University of Turin, Largo Paolo Braccini 2, 10095Grugliasco, Italy.
J Dairy Res. 2021 May;88(2):189-193. doi: 10.1017/S0022029921000315. Epub 2021 May 6.
In this study it is hypothesized that there are differences between immunoglobulin G (IgG) content in colostrum from beef (Chianina, Podolica) and dairy (Holstein Friesian) cows and that variables such as breed, and parity can influence IgG content. The further objective was to determine if these factors may vary in terms of sensitivity, specificity and the cut point when data obtained with the digital Brix refractometer is compared with the gold standard radial immunodiffusion assay (RID). A total of 90 samples of first-milking colostrum were collected within 2 h after parturition. IgG concentration was determined indirectly by digital Brix refractometer and directly by RID. Results obtained by RID were compared among breed and parity. For the digital Brix refractometer, sensitivity and specificity to detect colostrum with an IgG concentration lower than 50 g/l were calculated and the optimal cut-point was selected for each breed. Samples containing less than <50 g/l IgG accounted for 15.9% of the total. Parity influenced colostral IgG concentration and beef cows had a higher mean concentration of IgG (101.1 g/l in Chianina and 90.6 g/l in Podolica) than dairy cows (71.1 g/l in Holstein Friesian) First parity Chianina cows had the highest IgG mean content (116.1 g/l). At the optimal cut-point for Brix refractometer (20%) sensitivity and specificity were 0.93 (0.84-0.97) and 0.81 (0.70-0.88), however, a breed-related cut-point could be used to reduce evaluation error. Linear regression modeling showed that refractometer data were related to RID (r = 0.78). Results obtained suggest that breed and parity can influence IgG content of colostrum and, despite the Brix refractometer being an excellent on-farm tool, a breed-based definition of optimal cut point is needed.
在这项研究中,假设牛的初乳(奇亚纳纳牛、波德洛卡牛)和奶牛(荷斯坦弗里斯兰牛)的免疫球蛋白 G(IgG)含量存在差异,并且品种和胎次等变量可能会影响 IgG 含量。进一步的目标是确定当使用数字 Brix 折射计获得的数据与金标准放射免疫扩散测定(RID)进行比较时,这些因素在灵敏度、特异性和切点方面是否会有所不同。共收集了 90 份产后 2 小时内的初乳样本。通过数字 Brix 折射计间接和 RID 直接确定 IgG 浓度。比较了 RID 结果在品种和胎次之间的差异。对于数字 Brix 折射计,计算了用于检测 IgG 浓度低于 50 g/L 的初乳的灵敏度和特异性,并为每个品种选择了最佳切点。含有低于<50 g/L IgG 的样本占总数的 15.9%。胎次影响初乳 IgG 浓度,与奶牛相比,肉牛的 IgG 浓度更高(奇亚纳纳牛为 101.1 g/L,波德洛卡牛为 90.6 g/L),荷斯坦弗里斯兰牛为 71.1 g/L。第一胎奇亚纳纳牛的 IgG 平均含量最高(116.1 g/L)。对于 Brix 折射计的最佳切点(20%),灵敏度和特异性分别为 0.93(0.84-0.97)和 0.81(0.70-0.88),然而,使用基于品种的切点可以减少评估误差。线性回归模型显示折射计数据与 RID 相关(r=0.78)。研究结果表明,品种和胎次会影响初乳的 IgG 含量,尽管 Brix 折射计是一种出色的农场工具,但需要基于品种的最佳切点定义。