Chaney C
San Francisco State University, CA.
J Speech Hear Disord. 1988 Aug;53(3):252-61. doi: 10.1044/jshd.5303.252.
This study examined the identification of correctly produced and misarticulated /w, r, l, j/ in several subject groups: 4 normal children who produced correct /w, r, l, j/, 4 normal children with developmental w/r and w/l substitutions, 4 articulation-impaired children who misarticulated /r/ and /l/, a parent of each child, and two raters who were trained in phonetic transcription. Immediately following a production experiment in which the child subjects had produced minimally contrastive /w, r, l, j/ words in sentences, a selection of each child's utterances was randomly mixed with productions by an adult female speaker and were presented in minimally paired sets to each subject for identification of /w, r, l, j/. The children, parents, and raters were much more successful in identifying correctly produced semivowels than misarticulated ones. Misarticulating children and their parents differed from raters in approach to the task and in success. Analysis of individual subject data found that children who identified self-produced semivowels most successfully were the same children whose semivowels exhibited the most second formant frequency and transition rate differences in the previous production experiment. These results have both theoretical and therapeutic implications.
本研究考察了几个受试者组对正确发音和发音错误的/w、r、l、j/的辨别情况:4名能正确发出/w、r、l、j/的正常儿童,4名有发育性w/r和w/l替换的正常儿童,4名/r/和/l/发音错误的构音障碍儿童,每个孩子的一位家长,以及两名接受过语音转录培训的评分者。在一项产出实验之后,儿童受试者在句子中产出了最小对比的/w、r、l、j/单词,然后从每个孩子的话语中选出一部分与一位成年女性说话者的产出随机混合,并以最小配对的形式呈现给每个受试者,用于辨别/w、r、l、j/。儿童、家长和评分者在辨别正确发出的半元音方面比发音错误的半元音要成功得多。发音错误的儿童及其家长在任务方法和成功率上与评分者不同。对个体受试者数据的分析发现,在之前的产出实验中,那些能最成功辨别自己发出的半元音的儿童,其半元音在第二共振峰频率和过渡率上的差异也最大。这些结果具有理论和治疗意义。