Department of Telehealth, School of Nursing & Public Health, College of Health Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa.
Department of Computer Science, University of Botswana, Gaborone, Botswana.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2021 May 13;21(1):459. doi: 10.1186/s12913-021-06473-6.
mHealth presents innovative approaches to enhance primary healthcare delivery in developing countries like Botswana. The impact of mHealth solutions can be improved if they are interoperable with eRecord systems such as electronic health records, electronic medical records and patient health records. eHealth interoperability frameworks exist but their availability and utility for linking mHealth solutions to eRecords in developing world settings like Botswana is unknown. The recently adopted eHealth Strategy for Botswana recognises interoperability as an issue and mHealth as a potential solution for some healthcare needs, but does not address linking the two.
This study reviewed published reviews of eHealth interoperability frameworks for linking mHealth solutions with eRecords, and assessed their relevance to informing interoperability efforts with respect to Botswana's eHealth Strategy.
A structured literature review and analysis of published reviews of eHealth interoperability frameworks was performed to determine if any are relevant to linking mHealth with eRecords. The Botswanan eHealth Strategy was reviewed.
Four articles presented and reviewed eHealth interoperability frameworks that support linking of mHealth interventions to eRecords and associated implementation strategies. While the frameworks were developed for specific circumstances and therefore were based upon varying assumptions and perspectives, they entailed aspects that are relevant and could be drawn upon when developing an mHealth interoperability framework for Botswana. Common emerging themes of infrastructure, interoperability standards, data security and usability were identified and discussed; all of which are important in the developing world context such as in Botswana. The Botswana eHealth Strategy recognises interoperability, mHealth, and eRecords as distinct issues, but not linking of mHealth solutions with eRecords.
Delivery of healthcare is shifting from hospital-based to patient-centered primary healthcare and community-based settings, using mHealth interventions. The impact of mHealth solutions can be improved if data generated from them are converted into digital information ready for transmission and incorporation into eRecord systems. The Botswana eHealth Strategy stresses the need to have interoperable eRecords, but mHealth solutions must not be left out. Literature insight about mHealth interoperability with eRecords can inform implementation strategies for Botswana and elsewhere.
移动医疗为博茨瓦纳等发展中国家提供了增强初级医疗服务的创新方法。如果移动医疗解决方案与电子健康记录、电子病历和患者健康记录等电子记录系统实现互操作,其效果可以得到改善。现已有电子健康互操作性框架,但它们在博茨瓦纳等发展中国家的环境中用于将移动医疗解决方案与电子记录相连接的可用性和实用性尚不清楚。博茨瓦纳最近通过的电子健康战略认识到互操作性是一个问题,移动医疗是满足部分医疗需求的一种潜在解决方案,但并未涉及两者的连接。
本研究回顾了已发表的关于将移动医疗解决方案与电子记录相连接的电子健康互操作性框架的综述,并评估了它们对博茨瓦纳电子健康战略互操作性工作的相关性。
对已发表的电子健康互操作性框架的综述进行了结构化文献回顾和分析,以确定其中是否有与将移动医疗与电子记录相连接相关的内容。还对博茨瓦纳电子健康战略进行了审查。
有 4 篇文章提出并综述了支持将移动医疗干预措施与电子记录及其相关实施策略相连接的电子健康互操作性框架。虽然这些框架是为特定情况而制定的,因此基于不同的假设和观点,但它们涉及到在为博茨瓦纳制定移动医疗互操作性框架时可以借鉴的相关内容。确定并讨论了共同出现的基础设施、互操作性标准、数据安全性和可用性等主题;所有这些在博茨瓦纳等发展中国家的背景下都很重要。博茨瓦纳电子健康战略认识到互操作性、移动医疗和电子记录是不同的问题,但没有涉及将移动医疗解决方案与电子记录相连接。
医疗服务正在从以医院为基础向以患者为中心的初级医疗和社区为基础的环境转变,利用移动医疗干预措施。如果从移动医疗解决方案中生成的数据转换为可传输并纳入电子记录系统的数字信息,移动医疗解决方案的效果可以得到改善。博茨瓦纳电子健康战略强调需要具有互操作性的电子记录,但不能忽视移动医疗解决方案。关于移动医疗与电子记录互操作性的文献可以为博茨瓦纳和其他地方的实施策略提供信息。