Pierre Kevin, Rahmanian Kiarash P, Rooks Benjamin J, Solberg Lauren B
College of Medicine, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA.
Community Health & Family Medicine, University of Florida College of Medicine, Gainesville, Florida, USA.
J Med Ethics. 2022 May;48(5):338-342. doi: 10.1136/medethics-2020-107005. Epub 2021 May 14.
Physicians anecdotally report inquiring about incarcerated patients' crimes and their length of sentence, which has potential implications for the quality of care these patients receive. However, there is minimal research on how a physician's awareness of their patient's crimes/length of sentence impacts physician behaviours and attitudes. We performed regression modelling on a 27-question survey to analyse physician attitudes and behaviours towards incarcerated patients. We found that, although most physicians did not usually try to learn of their patients' crimes, they often became aware of them. We observed associations between awareness of a patient's crime and poor physician disposition towards their patients and between physicians' poor dispositions and lower reported quality of care. These associations suggest that awareness of a patient's crime may reduce quality of care by negatively impacting physicians' dispositions towards their patients. Future quantitative and qualitative studies, for example, involving physician interviews and direct patient outcome assessments, are needed to confirm these findings and further uncover and address hurdles incarcerated patients face in seeking medical care.
医生们称,他们会询问被监禁患者所犯罪行及其刑期,这可能会对这些患者所接受的护理质量产生影响。然而,关于医生对患者罪行/刑期的认知如何影响医生的行为和态度,相关研究极少。我们对一份包含27个问题的调查问卷进行了回归建模,以分析医生对被监禁患者的态度和行为。我们发现,虽然大多数医生通常不会试图了解患者的罪行,但他们往往会知晓这些情况。我们观察到,了解患者的罪行与医生对患者的不良态度之间存在关联,医生的不良态度与报告的较低护理质量之间也存在关联。这些关联表明,了解患者的罪行可能会通过对医生对患者的态度产生负面影响而降低护理质量。未来需要进行定量和定性研究,例如涉及医生访谈和直接的患者结果评估,以证实这些发现,并进一步揭示和解决被监禁患者在寻求医疗护理时面临的障碍。