Sheikh Goodarzi Mehdi, Jabbarian Amiri Bahman, Azarnivand Hossein, Waltner István
Department of Environmental Science and Engineering, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran.
Department of Range and Watershed Management, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran.
Heliyon. 2021 Apr 26;7(4):e06833. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e06833. eCollection 2021 Apr.
The aim of this study is to evaluate an alternative approach to indicate how hydrological processes behave in a given watershed, and to test whether this approach can replace traditional calibration, particularly under data deficient conditions. Therefore, a regional calibration method (RC) was adapted to characterize "parameter-based hydrologic processes" as a function of watershed ecologic attributes. The methodological process included (1) temporal phase, (2) correlation analysis and (3) spatial phase. The defined methodology was carried out on a 4160 km area containing 21 watersheds laying in the southern coastal line of the Caspian Sea, Iran. By implementing the RC, regional models were specified corresponding to each hydrological process defined in the Tank model. Testing the reliability of the transferring process of hydrological parameters was conducted using multi-level accuracy comparison (MAC) benefiting from descriptive statistics, scatter-plots and T-test. Both temporal and spatial phases have shown acceptable outputs backed by their ecologic significance, but as an alternative approach to traditional calibration, the standalone RC still needs development to achieve a more robust basis covering all the parameters of the hydrologic model. According to the post-processor MAC, the transferability of six out of twelve regional models (, , ) was accepted with respect to the given tests. As such, our method outperformed the number of transferable parameters by an outstanding regional model predicting the surface flow in comparison with similar studies. Although the RC could not achieve total perfection, nevertheless it could still help users by providing more information about the contribution of ecologic variables in the prediction of the hydrological processes of a certain watershed.
本研究的目的是评估一种替代方法,以表明水文过程在给定流域中的表现,并测试这种方法是否可以取代传统校准,特别是在数据不足的情况下。因此,采用了一种区域校准方法(RC)来将“基于参数的水文过程”表征为流域生态属性的函数。方法过程包括(1)时间阶段,(2)相关分析和(3)空间阶段。所定义的方法在一个4160平方公里的区域上实施,该区域包含位于伊朗里海南部海岸线的21个流域。通过实施RC,指定了与水箱模型中定义的每个水文过程相对应的区域模型。利用描述性统计、散点图和T检验,通过多级精度比较(MAC)对水文参数传递过程的可靠性进行了测试。时间和空间阶段都显示出可接受的输出,并具有生态学意义,但作为传统校准的替代方法,独立的RC仍需要进一步发展,以实现更稳健的基础,涵盖水文模型的所有参数。根据后处理器MAC,在给定测试中,十二个区域模型中的六个(,,)的可转移性被接受。因此,与类似研究相比,我们的方法通过一个预测地表径流的优秀区域模型在可转移参数数量上表现更优。尽管RC不能达到完全完美,但它仍然可以通过提供更多关于生态变量在特定流域水文过程预测中的贡献的信息来帮助用户。