Edwards Frank
UCLA Crim Justice Law Rev. 2020;4(1):157-164.
Many municipal governments have come to depend heavily on fines and fees generated by the criminal justice system. This essay uses data from all courts of limited jurisdiction (municipal and district courts) in Washington State between 2000 and 2014 to evaluate the relationships between local government finances, the Great Recession, and the imposition of debt through the criminal justice system. I find that municipalities issued more criminal justice debt during and after the recession across Washington, but that government finances as measured by tax receipts and expenditures per capita were weakly related to sentencing practices. These findings suggest that macroeconomic fiscal pressures may be drivers of enforcement and prosecutorial practices through increasing case volumes, but that macroeconomic pressures and local fiscal pressures did not appear to shift court sentencing practices in Washington during the Great Recession.
许多市政府已严重依赖刑事司法系统产生的罚款和费用。本文使用2000年至2014年期间华盛顿州所有有限管辖权法院(市法院和地方法院)的数据,来评估地方政府财政、大衰退以及通过刑事司法系统施加债务之间的关系。我发现,华盛顿州各地在衰退期间及之后,市政府发放了更多刑事司法债务,但以人均税收收入和支出衡量的政府财政与量刑做法的关联较弱。这些发现表明,宏观经济财政压力可能通过增加案件数量成为执法和检察做法的驱动因素,但在大衰退期间,宏观经济压力和地方财政压力似乎并未改变华盛顿州的法院量刑做法。