系统回顾手机恐惧症流行情况:揭示结果并为未来研究提供标准指南。
A systematic review on nomophobia prevalence: Surfacing results and standard guidelines for future research.
机构信息
Department of Psychology, Faculty of Education, Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR), Madrid, Spain.
Department of Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Universidad de Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain.
出版信息
PLoS One. 2021 May 18;16(5):e0250509. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0250509. eCollection 2021.
BACKGROUND
Mobile phones allow us to stay connected with others and provide us a sense of security. We can work, chat with family and friends, take pictures, buy clothes or books, and even control home appliances. They play such a significant role in our lives that we feel anxious without them. In some cases, the relationship between humans and these communication devices have become problematic. Nomophobia (NMP) is the fear of becoming incommunicable, separated from the mobile phone and losing connection to the Internet. Since this social phobia was coined in the first decade of the XXI century, a growing number of studies have studied it and reported the prevalence of this technology-related problem. However, this research activity has generated mixed results regarding how we assess and report nomophobia and who may be at a higher risk of suffering or developing it.
METHODS
We conducted a systematic review of 108 studies published in English and Spanish and collected them in Parsifal. We searched for assessment and prevalence data on nomophobia. Also, we looked at gender and age differences to identify risk factors and see if these differences exist and emerge worldwide.
RESULTS
In this study, we find that women and younger individuals suffer more from nomophobia. The disparity in reporting the prevalence of nomophobia is enormous since the percentages of "at-risk" participants go from 13% to 79%, and participants suffering from it are between 6% and 73%, being the score in the range of 45.5 and 93.82. Within the group of nomophobic people, moderate cases vary between 25.7% and 73.3%, and severe cases, between 1% and 87%. Such disparity is due to differences in assessment criteria. Females and young people seem to be more vulnerable to nomophobia although methodological disparity makes it difficult to reach definitive conclusions. We conclude our review by recommending some common guidelines for guiding future research.
背景
手机让我们与他人保持联系,并带给我们安全感。我们可以工作、与家人和朋友聊天、拍照、购买衣服或书籍,甚至可以控制家电。它们在我们的生活中扮演着如此重要的角色,如果没有它们,我们会感到焦虑。在某些情况下,人类与这些通讯设备之间的关系已经出现问题。无手机恐惧症(NMP)是指害怕无法交流、与手机分离以及失去与互联网的连接。自从这种社交恐惧症在 21 世纪的第一个十年被提出以来,越来越多的研究对其进行了研究,并报告了这种与技术相关的问题的流行程度。然而,关于我们如何评估和报告无手机恐惧症以及谁可能更容易患上或发展这种疾病,这项研究活动产生了不同的结果。
方法
我们对以英语和西班牙语发表的 108 项研究进行了系统综述,并在 Parsifal 中对其进行了收集。我们搜索了无手机恐惧症的评估和流行数据。此外,我们还研究了性别和年龄差异,以确定风险因素,并观察这些差异是否存在且在全球范围内出现。
结果
在这项研究中,我们发现女性和年轻人更容易受到无手机恐惧症的影响。报告无手机恐惧症流行率的差异非常大,因为“有风险”参与者的百分比从 13%到 79%不等,而患有这种疾病的参与者的百分比在 6%到 73%之间,分数在 45.5 到 93.82 之间。在无手机恐惧症患者群体中,中度病例在 25.7%到 73.3%之间变化,而严重病例在 1%到 87%之间变化。这种差异是由于评估标准的差异造成的。女性和年轻人似乎更容易受到无手机恐惧症的影响,尽管方法上的差异使得难以得出明确的结论。我们通过推荐一些指导未来研究的通用指南来结束我们的综述。