Max Näder Lab for Rehabilitation Technologies and Outcomes Research, Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Chicago, USA.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, USA.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2021 May 25;18(1):88. doi: 10.1186/s12984-021-00879-3.
Individuals with transfemoral amputations who are considered to be limited community ambulators are classified as Medicare functional classification (MFCL) level K2. These individuals are usually prescribed a non-microprocessor controlled knee (NMPK) with an appropriate foot for simple walking functions. However, existing research suggests that these individuals can benefit from using a microprocessor controlled knee (MPK) and appropriate foot for their ambulation, but cannot obtain one due to insurance policy restrictions. With a steady increase in older adults with amputations due to vascular conditions, it is critical to evaluate whether advanced prostheses can provide better safety and performance capabilities to maintain and improve quality of life in individuals who are predominantly designated MFCL level K2. To decipher this we conducted a 13 month longitudinal clinical trial to determine the benefits of using a C-Leg and 1M10 foot in individuals at K2 level with transfemoral amputation due to vascular disease. This longitudinal clinical trial incorporated recommendations prescribed by the lower limb prosthesis workgroup to design a study that can add evidence to improve reimbursement policy through clinical outcomes using an MPK in K2 level individuals with transfemoral amputation who were using an NMPK for everyday use.
Ten individuals (mean age: 63 ± 9 years) with unilateral transfemoral amputation due to vascular conditions designated as MFCL K2 participated in this longitudinal crossover randomized clinical trial. Baseline outcomes were collected with their current prosthesis. Participants were then randomized to one of two groups, either an intervention with the MPK with a standardized 1M10 foot or their predicate NMPK with a standardized 1M10 foot. On completion of the first intervention, participants crossed over to the next group to complete the study. Each intervention lasted for 6 months (3 months of acclimation and 3 months of take-home trial to monitor home use). At the end of each intervention, clinical outcomes and self-reported outcomes were collected to compare with their baseline performance. A generalized linear model ANOVA was used to compare the performance of each intervention with respect to their own baseline.
Statistically significant and clinically meaningful improvements were observed in gait performance, safety, and participant-reported measures when using the MPK C-Leg + 1M10 foot. Most participants were able to achieve higher clinical scores in gait speed, balance, self-reported mobility, and fall safety, while using the MPK + 1M10 combination. The improvement in scores were within range of scores achieved by individuals with K3 functional level as reported in previous studies.
Individuals with transfemoral amputation from dysvascular conditions designated MFCL level K2 benefited from using an MPK + appropriate foot. The inference and evidence from this longitudinal clinical trial will add to the knowledgebase related to reimbursement policy-making. Trial registration This study is registered on clinical trials.gov with the study title "Functional outcomes in dysvascular transfemoral amputees" and the associated ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01537211. The trial was retroactively registered on February 7, 2012 after the first participant was enrolled.
被认为是社区有限活动能力的股骨截肢者被归类为医疗保险功能分类(MFCL)水平 K2。这些人通常被开处方使用非微处理器控制的膝关节(NMPK)和适当的脚来实现简单的步行功能。然而,现有研究表明,这些人可以从使用微处理器控制的膝关节(MPK)和适当的脚中受益,以实现他们的活动能力,但由于保险政策的限制,他们无法获得。随着血管疾病导致的老年截肢者数量的稳步增加,评估高级假肢是否可以为主要被指定为 MFCL 水平 K2 的人提供更好的安全性和性能能力,以维持和提高他们的生活质量至关重要。为了解决这个问题,我们进行了一项为期 13 个月的纵向临床试验,以确定在血管疾病导致的股骨截肢者中,使用 C-Leg 和 1M10 脚对 MFCL 水平 K2 患者的益处。这项纵向临床试验采用了下肢假肢工作组推荐的建议,旨在通过使用 MPK 的临床结果来设计一项研究,为改善通过使用 MPK 来改善 K2 水平的血管疾病导致的股骨截肢者的报销政策提供证据,这些患者目前正在使用 NMPK 进行日常使用。
10 名(平均年龄:63±9 岁)因血管疾病导致单侧股骨截肢的患者被指定为 MFCL K2,参加了这项纵向交叉随机临床试验。在使用当前假肢时收集基线结果。然后,参与者被随机分配到两组中的一组,一组是使用标准化 1M10 脚的 MPK 干预组,另一组是使用标准化 1M10 脚的他们的预测性 NMPK 组。在完成第一次干预后,参与者交叉到下一组完成研究。每个干预持续 6 个月(3 个月适应期和 3 个月家庭试用期,以监测家庭使用情况)。在每次干预结束时,收集临床结果和自我报告结果,以与基线表现进行比较。使用广义线性模型 ANOVA 比较了每次干预相对于其自身基线的表现。
当使用 MPK C-Leg+1M10 脚时,观察到步态表现、安全性和参与者报告的测量有统计学意义和临床意义的改善。大多数参与者在使用 MPK+1M10 组合时能够获得更高的临床步态速度、平衡、自我报告的移动性和跌倒安全性评分。这些评分的提高范围在先前研究中报告的 K3 功能水平的个体所达到的评分范围内。
血管疾病导致的股骨截肢者(MFCL 水平 K2)从使用 MPK+适当的脚中受益。这项纵向临床试验的推论和证据将为报销政策制定的知识库增添内容。
这项研究在 clinicaltrials.gov 上注册,研究标题为“血管疾病导致的股骨截肢者的功能结果”,并与 ClinicalTrials.gov 标识符相关联:NCT01537211。该试验于 2012 年 2 月 7 日在首次入组后进行了追溯性注册。