Department of Drug Metabolism and Pharmacokinetics, Janssen Pharmaceutica NV, B-2340 Beerse, Belgium.
Department of Computer and Systems Sciences, Stockholm University, P.O. Box 7003, SE-164 07 Kista, Sweden.
J Chem Inf Model. 2021 Jun 28;61(6):2648-2657. doi: 10.1021/acs.jcim.1c00208. Epub 2021 May 27.
Predictive modeling for toxicity can help reduce risks in a range of applications and potentially serve as the basis for regulatory decisions. However, the utility of these predictions can be limited if the associated uncertainty is not adequately quantified. With recent studies showing great promise for deep learning-based models also for toxicity predictions, we investigate the combination of deep learning-based predictors with the conformal prediction framework to generate highly predictive models with well-defined uncertainties. We use a range of deep feedforward neural networks and graph neural networks in a conformal prediction setting and evaluate their performance on data from the Tox21 challenge. We also compare the results from the conformal predictors to those of the underlying machine learning models. The results indicate that highly predictive models can be obtained that result in very efficient conformal predictors even at high confidence levels. Taken together, our results highlight the utility of conformal predictors as a convenient way to deliver toxicity predictions with confidence, adding both statistical guarantees on the model performance as well as better predictions of the minority class compared to the underlying models.
毒性预测模型有助于降低一系列应用中的风险,并且可能成为监管决策的基础。然而,如果相关不确定性没有得到充分量化,这些预测的实用性可能会受到限制。最近的研究表明,基于深度学习的模型在毒性预测方面也有很大的潜力,因此我们研究了将基于深度学习的预测器与一致性预测框架相结合,以生成具有明确定义不确定性的高预测性模型。我们在一致性预测设置中使用了一系列深度前馈神经网络和图神经网络,并在 Tox21 挑战赛的数据上评估了它们的性能。我们还将一致性预测器的结果与基础机器学习模型的结果进行了比较。结果表明,可以获得高预测性模型,即使在高置信水平下,也可以得到非常高效的一致性预测器。总之,我们的结果强调了一致性预测器作为一种方便的方法来提供具有信心的毒性预测的实用性,为模型性能提供了统计保证,并且与基础模型相比,对少数类别的预测更好。