Moser E, Pickardt C R, Mann K, Engelhardt D, Kirsch C M, Knesewitsch P, Tatsch K, Kreisig T, Kurz C, Saller B
Radiologische Klinik des Klinikums Grosshadern der Universität, München, BRD.
Nuklearmedizin. 1988 Jun;27(3):98-104.
The aim of this study was to check the efficacy of radioiodine (131I) therapy (RIT) in a large number of patients (n = 506) suffering from immunogenic or non-immunogenic hyperthyroidism (Graves' disease, Plummer's disease). Since there is no causal cure for immunogenic hyperthyroidism RIT provides, like all other modalities, only a moderate rate of success which is clearly dose-related. Applying 60 Gy, normal thyroid function can be achieved in only 54% of the cases. A dose of 150 Gy succeeds in 86% of the cases. The solitary decompensated autonomous adenoma (DAA) can be eliminated surgically as well as by RIT with a high degree of success (95%). Contrary to surgery, RIT does not have any noticeable early or late morbidity. The high rate of success of RIT in patients with DAA could be confirmed in two groups with different follow-up periods (16 and 65 months). As expected, the rate of hypothyroidism increased from 11% in the early group to 23% in the late group. Multinodular autonomous adenomas can be eliminated successfully using RIT as well. The concept to apply a dose of 400 Gy to the total functional autonomous tissue as determined by ultrasound yields better results (95%) than 150 Gy to the whole thyroid gland as measured by ultrasound (88%). The rate of hypothyroidism as shown by these results (up to a maximum of 62% after RIT of Graves' disease using 150 Gy) is the lesser evil compared to remaining or recurrent hyperthyroidism since these patients can be treated with thyroid hormones without problems.
本研究的目的是检验放射性碘(¹³¹I)治疗(RIT)对大量免疫性或非免疫性甲状腺功能亢进症(格雷夫斯病、普卢默病)患者(n = 506)的疗效。由于免疫性甲状腺功能亢进症没有因果性治愈方法,RIT与所有其他治疗方式一样,成功率仅为中等,且明显与剂量相关。应用60 Gy时,仅54%的病例可实现甲状腺功能正常。150 Gy的剂量在86%的病例中成功。孤立性失代偿自主性腺瘤(DAA)可通过手术以及RIT成功消除(成功率95%)。与手术不同,RIT没有任何明显的早期或晚期发病率。RIT在DAA患者中的高成功率在两个不同随访期(16个月和65个月)的组中得到证实。正如预期的那样,甲状腺功能减退的发生率从早期组的11%增加到晚期组的23%。多结节自主性腺瘤也可通过RIT成功消除。根据超声确定对全部功能性自主组织应用400 Gy剂量的概念,比根据超声对整个甲状腺应用150 Gy剂量产生更好的结果(95%对88%)。这些结果显示的甲状腺功能减退发生率(格雷夫斯病使用150 Gy进行RIT后最高可达62%)与残留或复发性甲状腺功能亢进相比是较小的危害,因为这些患者可以毫无问题地用甲状腺激素进行治疗。