Cryder Brian T, Lee Michelle M, Workman Gloria M, Krumdick Nathaniel
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Midwestern University College of Pharmacy - Downers Grove, 555 31(st) Street, Downers Grove, IL 60515, United States.
Department of Behavioral Sciences, Midwestern University College of Health Sciences, 555 31(st) Street, Downers Grove, IL 60515, United States.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2021 Jul;13(7):753-759. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2021.03.024. Epub 2021 Apr 5.
To identify (1) how often and in what settings pharmacy students include spirituality and religion and (2) what factors may influence how often students incorporate spirituality in patient care plans.
Fourth-year pharmacy students completed a questionnaire defining the frequency and setting of patient care activities that incorporated spiritual beliefs during advanced pharmacy practice experiences. Demographics, prior spirituality and health coursework, and self-identified measures of religiosity and spirituality were collected. Data analysis utilized descriptive statistics with nonparametric exploratory analysis.
Sixty-three students completed the survey (31.7% response rate). While 11% of students asked patients about spiritual needs, 25.4% reported inclusion of spiritual factors in therapeutic plan creation. The general medicine rotation was the most common setting identified. Student frequency of religious service attendance, self-identified religiosity, and self-reported spirituality were associated with perceived importance of asking patients about spiritual needs (P < .05 for all). This did not impact whether students asked about or incorporated these topics (P > .05 for all). Students who did ask about or incorporate spiritual and religious issues had significantly greater comfort in discussing these and referring patients to a chaplain (P < .05 for all).
Students are considering patients' spiritual needs in patient care activities. Greater student spiritual and religious practices positively influenced attitudes toward importance of asking about patient needs but did not influence student-reported behavior in patient care. Results highlight the need for instructors to consider how students' comfort levels and patient care setting influence addressing spiritual concerns.
确定(1)药学专业学生在何种频率以及在何种环境下将灵性与宗教纳入其中,以及(2)哪些因素可能影响学生在患者护理计划中纳入灵性的频率。
四年级药学专业学生完成了一份问卷,问卷确定了在高级药学实践经验中纳入精神信仰的患者护理活动的频率和环境。收集了人口统计学信息、之前的灵性与健康课程作业,以及自我认定的宗教信仰和灵性测量指标。数据分析采用描述性统计和非参数探索性分析。
63名学生完成了调查(回复率为31.7%)。虽然11%的学生询问患者的精神需求,但25.4%的学生报告在制定治疗计划时纳入了精神因素。综合内科轮转是最常见的确定环境。学生参加宗教仪式的频率、自我认定的宗教信仰以及自我报告的灵性与询问患者精神需求的感知重要性相关(所有P值均<0.05)。这并未影响学生是否询问或纳入这些话题(所有P值均>0.05)。确实询问或纳入灵性与宗教问题的学生在讨论这些问题以及将患者转介给牧师方面明显更自在(所有P值均<0.05)。
学生在患者护理活动中考虑患者的精神需求。学生更多的灵性与宗教实践对询问患者需求重要性的态度有积极影响,但并未影响学生报告的患者护理行为。结果凸显了教师需要考虑学生的自在程度和患者护理环境如何影响解决精神问题。