Institute of Health and Care Sciences, Sahlgrenska Academy, Gothenburg Centre for Person Centred Care, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine, Region Västra Götaland, Sahlgrenska University Hospital/Östra, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Scand J Caring Sci. 2022 Dec;36(4):1083-1093. doi: 10.1111/scs.13005. Epub 2021 Jun 1.
Ageism in nursing, particularly regarding oldest-old adults (age ≥80 years), adversely affects patient safety and care quality. Nurse education can reduce ageist attitudes. Swedish and Austrian nursing students' attitudes towards adults age ≥80 years have not been assessed.
To analyse attitudes towards adults age ≥80 years among nursing students from universities in Sweden and Austria.
A prospective cross-sectional survey including the four-factor, 26-item validated Ageing Semantic Differential scale and demographic questions.
A pen-and-paper survey was administered to nursing students at the Medical University of Graz, Austria (May-June 2019); an online survey was conducted at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden (January-June 2020). Demographic data were analysed descriptively; means and individual item ratings were calculated for each country. Multiple logistic regression was performed for each factor of the instrument: (1) Instrumentality, (2) Autonomy, (3) Acceptability and (4) Integrity. Six independent variables were included in the regression analysis.
In total, 136 Austrian and 222 Swedish students responded (88% women). Compared with Austrian students, Swedish students were older and had more positive attitudes about oldest-old adults. Swedish students' median factor ratings (7-point scale) were 3.62 (Factor 1), 3.50 (Factor 2), 2.71 (Factor 3) and 3.80 (Factor 4). Austrian students' median ratings were 4.25 (Factor 1), 3.83 (Factor 2), 3.28 (Factor 3) and 4.00 (Factor 4). Regression analyses showed that the variables country, older family member/acquaintance, and age were associated with the different factors.
Compared with Austrian students, Swedish students' attitudes towards oldest-old adults were more favourable. We discussed the findings at individual, interpersonal/intergroup and societal/cultural levels and present implications for education and research.
Nurse education should address ageism as a multilevel phenomenon, and include the person-centred care perspective. Further research comparing nursing students' attitudes from different cultures is needed.
护理领域的年龄歧视,特别是针对最年长老年人(年龄≥80 岁)的年龄歧视,会对患者安全和护理质量产生不利影响。护士教育可以减少年龄歧视态度。瑞典和奥地利护理学生对≥80 岁成年人的态度尚未得到评估。
分析瑞典和奥地利大学护理学生对≥80 岁成年人的态度。
前瞻性横断面调查,包括经过验证的四因素 26 项老龄化语义差异量表和人口统计学问题。
2019 年 5 月至 6 月,在奥地利格拉茨医科大学进行纸笔问卷调查;2020 年 1 月至 6 月,在瑞典哥德堡大学进行在线调查。对人口统计学数据进行描述性分析;计算每个国家的平均值和各单项评分。对工具的每个因子(1)工具性、(2)自主性、(3)可接受性和(4)完整性进行多因素逻辑回归。回归分析纳入了 6 个独立变量。
共有 136 名奥地利学生和 222 名瑞典学生(88%为女性)做出回应。与奥地利学生相比,瑞典学生年龄较大,对最年长老年人的态度更为积极。瑞典学生的中位数因子评分(7 分制)为 3.62(因子 1)、3.50(因子 2)、2.71(因子 3)和 3.80(因子 4)。奥地利学生的中位数评分分别为 4.25(因子 1)、3.83(因子 2)、3.28(因子 3)和 4.00(因子 4)。回归分析表明,国家、年长的家庭成员/熟人以及年龄等变量与不同因子有关。
与奥地利学生相比,瑞典学生对最年长老年人的态度更为有利。我们在个人、人际/群体以及社会/文化层面讨论了研究结果,并提出了教育和研究的启示。
护士教育应将年龄歧视视为一个多层次的现象,并纳入以人为本的护理视角。需要进一步研究不同文化背景的护理学生的态度。