Department of Clinical Science and Education, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Emergency and Disaster Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences (USWR), Tehran, Iran.
Iran J Med Sci. 2021 May;46(3):198-206. doi: 10.30476/ijms.2020.84023.1342.
The healthcare system in Iran has undergone several reforms to achieve the objectives of universal health coverage (UHC). Some reforms have delivered positive benefits, however, still many challenges remain. Hence, the current study assessed the progress and outcomes of these reforms over the past three decades.
The present nationwide macro-qualitative study was conducted in Iran during 2016-2017. Data were collected through 32 in-depth interviews with 30 high-ranking policymakers and healthcare providers at the national and provincial levels to identify their experiences and perceptions of the reforms. The data were analyzed using the constant comparative analysis method.
Analysis of the interview data resulted in two main themes, six categories, and 18 sub-categories. The extracted themes were adverse situational context and the chaotic healthcare system. The results showed that the Iranian healthcare system reforms could be characterized as incoherent and passive, and that these were the main reasons for not achieving the objectives of UHC reforms. It was revealed that the implemented reforms lacked a comprehensive approach and at times were counterproductive. Moreover, the situational context adversely hindered the successful implementation of the reforms.
Despite many efforts to improve the Iranian healthcare system through reforms, the situational context and organizational factors have prevented achieving the main objectives. Iran's health policymakers should consider a phased implementation of small-scale reforms based on a comprehensive master plan that takes social, political, and economic factors into account. This approach would minimize potential risks and encourages the cooperation of the main stakeholders.
伊朗的医疗体系经历了多次改革,以实现全民健康覆盖(UHC)的目标。一些改革带来了积极的好处,但仍存在许多挑战。因此,本研究评估了过去三十年来这些改革的进展和成果。
本研究是 2016 年至 2017 年期间在伊朗进行的一项全国性宏观定性研究。通过对 30 名来自国家和省级的高级政策制定者和医疗保健提供者进行的 32 次深入访谈,收集了数据,以了解他们对改革的经验和看法。采用恒定性比较分析方法对数据进行分析。
对访谈数据的分析产生了两个主题、六个类别和 18 个子类别。提取的主题是不利的情境背景和混乱的医疗体系。结果表明,伊朗的医疗体系改革可以被描述为不协调和被动,这是未能实现 UHC 改革目标的主要原因。研究结果表明,实施的改革缺乏全面的方法,有时甚至适得其反。此外,情境背景也对改革的成功实施产生了不利影响。
尽管伊朗通过改革努力改善了其医疗体系,但情境背景和组织因素阻碍了主要目标的实现。伊朗的卫生政策制定者应考虑根据一个全面的总体规划,分阶段实施小规模改革,该规划应考虑到社会、政治和经济因素。这种方法将最小化潜在风险,并鼓励主要利益相关者的合作。