Feng Hui, Shi Gaofeng, Liu Hui, Du Yu, Zhang Ning, Wang Yaning
Department of Radiology, The Fourth Hospital of Hebei Medical University, Shijiazhuang, China.
Front Oncol. 2021 May 18;11:649625. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2021.649625. eCollection 2021.
This study aimed to evaluate the visibility of different subgroups of lung nodules of <3 cm using the pointwise encoding time reduction with radial acquisition (PETRA) sequence on 3T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in comparison with that obtained using low-dose computed tomography (LDCT).
The appropriate detection rate was calculated for each of the different subgroups of lung nodules of <3 cm. The mean diameter of each detected nodule was determined. The detection rates and diameters of the lung nodules detected by MRI with the PETRA sequence were compared with those detected by computed tomography (CT). The sensitivity of detection for the different subgroups of pulmonary nodules was determined based on the location, size, type of nodules and morphologic characteristics. Agreement of nodule characteristics between CT and MRI were assessed by intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and Kappa test.
The CT scans detected 256 lung nodules, comprising 99 solid nodules (SNs) and 157 subsolid nodules with a mean nodule diameter of 8.3 mm. For the SNs, the MRI detected 30/47 nodules of <6 mm in diameter and 52/52 nodules of ≥6 mm in diameter. For the subsolid nodules, the MRI detected 30/51 nodules of <6 mm in diameter and 102/106 nodules of ≥6 mm in diameter. The PETRA sequence returned a high detection rate (84%). The detection rates of SN, ground glass nodules, and PSN were 82%, 72%, and 94%, respectively. For nodules with a diameter of >6 mm, the sensitivity of the PETRA sequence reached 97%, with a higher rate for nodules located in the upper lung fields than those in the middle and lower lung fields. Strong agreement was found between the CT and PETRA results (correlation coefficients = 0.97).
The PETRA technique had high sensitivity for different type of nodule detection and enabled accurate assessment of their diameter and morphologic characteristics. It may be an effective alternative to CT as a tool for screening and follow up pulmonary nodules.
本研究旨在评估在3T磁共振成像(MRI)上使用径向采集的逐点编码时间减少(PETRA)序列对直径<3 cm的不同亚组肺结节的可视性,并与低剂量计算机断层扫描(LDCT)进行比较。
计算直径<3 cm的不同亚组肺结节各自的合适检测率。确定每个检测到的结节的平均直径。将PETRA序列MRI检测到的肺结节的检测率和直径与计算机断层扫描(CT)检测到的进行比较。根据结节的位置、大小、类型和形态特征确定肺结节不同亚组的检测敏感性。通过组内相关系数(ICC)和Kappa检验评估CT和MRI之间结节特征的一致性。
CT扫描检测到256个肺结节,包括99个实性结节(SN)和157个亚实性结节,平均结节直径为8.3 mm。对于SN,MRI检测到直径<6 mm的结节中有30/47个,直径≥6 mm的结节中有52/52个。对于亚实性结节,MRI检测到直径<6 mm的结节中有30/51个,直径≥6 mm的结节中有102/106个。PETRA序列返回了较高的检测率(84%)。SN、磨玻璃结节和部分实性结节的检测率分别为82%、72%和94%。对于直径>6 mm的结节,PETRA序列的敏感性达到97%,位于上肺野的结节的检测率高于中肺野和下肺野的结节。CT和PETRA结果之间发现高度一致性(相关系数 = 0.97)。
PETRA技术对不同类型结节的检测具有高敏感性,能够准确评估其直径和形态特征。它可能是作为肺结节筛查和随访工具的CT的有效替代方法。