Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University Hospital Ulm, Prittwitzstraße 43, 89075, Ulm, Germany.
Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2022 Jan;305(1):19-29. doi: 10.1007/s00404-021-06102-x. Epub 2021 Jun 4.
Evaluation of a novel ultrasound-simulation-app for training fetal echocardiography as a possible useful addition for students, residents and specialist doctors. Furthermore, comparison to a conventional learning-method with special attention on orientation and recognition of physiological structures.
Prospective two-arm study with the participation of 226 clinical students. 108 students were given an extract from a textbook on fetal echocardiography (PDF-group, n = 108) for 30 min to study. 118 students were able to use the new ultrasound-simulator-app (Simulator-group, n = 118) to learn for 30 min. The knowledge of the students was examined both before and after the learning-period by having them identify sonographic structures in videos using single-choice selection.
There were no significant differences between the two groups regarding age (p = 0.87), gender (p = 0.28), and the number of previously performed ultrasound-examinations (p = 0.45). In the Simulator-group, there was a significantly higher learning effect regarding the proportion of students with an increase of correct answers in the video test examination (p = 0.005). At the end of learning, the students in the Simulator-group needed significantly less time to display the structures in the app's simulation (median initially 10.9 s vs. 6.8 s at the end; p < 0.001).
The novel ultrasound-simulation-app seems to be a useful addition and improvement to ultrasound training. Previous difficulties such as simultaneously having patients, ultrasound-machines, and professors at disposal can thus be avoided. This means that another important step towards remote learning can be taken, which has been proven increasingly essential lately, due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
评估一种新型的超声模拟应用程序,用于培训胎儿超声心动图,作为学生、住院医师和专科医生的有用补充。此外,与传统学习方法进行比较,特别关注生理结构的定位和识别。
前瞻性双臂研究,共 226 名临床学生参与。108 名学生(PDF 组,n=108)获得胎儿超声心动图教科书的摘录,学习 30 分钟。118 名学生(模拟器组,n=118)可以使用新的超声模拟器应用程序学习 30 分钟。在学习前后,通过让学生在视频中使用单项选择来识别超声结构,检查学生的知识。
两组在年龄(p=0.87)、性别(p=0.28)和之前进行的超声检查次数(p=0.45)方面无显著差异。在模拟器组中,在视频测试中正确答案比例增加的学生比例有显著更高的学习效果(p=0.005)。在学习结束时,模拟器组的学生在应用程序模拟中显示结构所需的时间明显减少(中位数初始为 10.9 秒,结束时为 6.8 秒;p<0.001)。
新型超声模拟应用程序似乎是超声培训的有用补充和改进。因此,可以避免同时拥有患者、超声机和教授的先前困难。这意味着可以朝着远程学习迈出另一个重要的步骤,由于 COVID-19 大流行,远程学习最近变得越来越重要。